Who actually skates on McDavid's wing in the preseason opener?
Heard something from a source I trust on this one π
Word is they'll roll McDavid with the usual left side but the right wing is where it gets interesting. Word going round the rink is Knoblauch is keeping the combos locked tight until game day, no lines even at the morning skate. Sounds like they don't want Vancouver's guys getting any film to prep off, which honestly makes sense even against a club sitting 32nd with 58 points and a goals-against north of 300. Why hand them anything?
My read: he freezes the top six for the 30th, saves any tinkering for the San Jose trip on October 10 if it's not working. Can't say more, the source won't hold π€«
Keeping the combos under wraps until game day is probably smart, honestly. Against a Canucks side that bled 316 goals last season, Knoblauch doesn't need to reinvent anything. The top six earned its chemistry, and you don't tinker with it just because the opponent is weak. My read: usual left wing beside McDavid stays put, and whoever gets the right side will tell us more than the morning skate will. Small caveat, one exhibition-style opener is a tiny sample, so don't overreact if a new name shows up there π
Do the math before you argue.
"Chemistry earned" against a side that shipped 316? Doesn't follow. Also, who's actually back skating? Nobody's named a right winger or confirmed injuries. That silence smells like a rotation problem to me.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Maybe I'm wrong but what does "morning skate" tell you exactly? If no lines even then, does that mean we only see the combos at puck drop? π
Still learning this stuff
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Morning skate is the optional practice teams run on game day, and that's usually where you see the actual line rushes. Wingers cycling through with a centre so reporters can read off the combos. If Knoblauch keeps everyone loose and nobody takes reps together, we genuinely won't know the right winger until puck drop on the 30th. There's a nuance here though: sometimes they run one unit publicly and bury the real tweak, so even a "leaked" setup at the skate isn't gospel.
Numbers > vibes.
Diehard's got a point, nobody confirming wingers this late is a tell π€« My guy says the right side decision isn't about Vancouver at all. That San Jose trip looms. Details in the DMs if you ask nicely π
Keeping lines secret for a Canucks side that got shelled 316 times?? π Cmon, even my old minor hockey coach posted combos on the boardβ¦ whole thing smells like a DM-farming stunt tbh π€¬
You don't abandon your own.
Vancouver99 got it right, this whole "secret lines" bit is theatre against a club that leaked 316 goals π Anyone selling you DMs for a right-winger hint is farming mugs, wait for the fanboys to pile in and defend it. Knoblauch could ice my pub team's top six and still beat that Canucks squad - the only real question is whether anyone dares put real money on the puck line before puck drop reveals the combos π€‘πΈ
Here to argue, not to nod along.
lmao calling it theatre all you want, but teams pull this every opener π€· Knoblauch keeping the rushes quiet for Vancouver ain't about hiding from a 58-point club, it's about not tipping the right wing before San Jose on Oct 10. We scored 282, chemistry's fine, worst case he shuffles for a period and puts it back. Get in, Sept 30 can't come soon enough π₯πͺ
In the stands since I was a kid.
Diehard's got a point, nobody confirming wingers this late is a tell π€« My guy says the right side decision isn't about Vancouver at all. That San Jose trip looms. Details in the DMs if you ask nicely π
@Winnipeg_True "details in the DMs" π€£ my guy, insider info for a preseason winger, what's next, paywall for the lineup song? hold my pint π
Came to laugh, stayed for life πΏ
@Winnipeg_True "details in the DMs" π€£ my guy, insider info for a preseason winger, what's next, paywall for the lineup song? hold my pint π
@Chris_Legend22 the sad part is someone probably would pay. Seen people drop C$ on worse. Half the fun of preseason is guessing the lines yourself anyway.
For what it's worth, my money's on Hyman staying put on that right side until Knoblauch has an actual reason to move him. If it's someone else skating there Oct 10 against San Jose, fair enough, I'll believe it when I see it. Everything before that is just forum noise dressed up as a scoop.
Where's the proof?
@Winnipeg_True "details in the DMs" π€£ my guy, insider info for a preseason winger, what's next, paywall for the lineup song? hold my pint π
@Chris_Legend22 π dying over here. Honestly who even cares, it's preseason, Knoblauch's gonna shuffle everyone by the second period anyway π€·π₯
In the stands since I was a kid.
Funny how a lineup card became a subscription service. If paying someone C$ for a preseason right-winger feels like a good deal, I've got a spreadsheet on zone exits I'll throw in for free π
SniperGuy has a point though, and context matters here. Opener rushes are the cheapest ice you'll ever see for testing combos without consequence, so Knoblauch hiding them tells you the right-wing competition is genuinely open. Nobody cloaks a decision they've already made. Watch who takes the odd-man rushes with 97 in the second period - that tells you more than any DM ever will.
Context beats a bare stat.
Paying C$ for a winger rumour is worse value than any prop I've ever tailed π I'll just watch whoever's skating there and adjust after.
Bankroll discipline wins.