Makar is brilliant, but this defence has been carried so hard that
Makar could win the Norris playing with a traffic cone and some of you would still call this defence "fine". Since Toews went down the second pair is eating 22+ minutes a night and even-strength goals against have doubled, that's a unit carried, not a unit. But sure, tell me again it's just a slump 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.
22+ minutes for a second pair reads more like a depth problem than Makar carrying anyone. I'll believe "carried" when someone shows the actual share of TOI.
Hype isn't an argument.
PuckheadDad does have a point that it's a depth problem, but that's exactly why the "carried" label fits 😤 our lot never make it easy. Toews goes down and suddenly the second pair is chugging 22+ a night like they're a first unit, and even-strength goals against have doubled. That's not a blip, that's Cale dragging a patched-together blue line up the mountain every single shift.
Remember when Toews and Makar could just shut down anyone's top line and we'd all head to the pub relaxed? Now I'm white-knuckling every cycle against our end. Makar plays 28 hard minutes, eats the toughest matchups, and still wins you games off the point... if that's not carrying, what is? 🏔💪 There's no puck line big enough for how much we're asking of one guy tbh. Bednar's gotta protect him before this gets uglier.
You don't abandon your own.
I keep a running sheet on this stuff and the Toews numbers jump off the page at me every night. Second pair past 22 minutes a game since he went out, and even-strength goals against doubled in that stretch. You can argue about the label all you want, but a pair eating that workload while the GA doubles is getting dragged through games, simple as that. 📊 It's a depth problem and a carrying problem at the same time, context matters here.
Context beats a bare stat.
Back when Erik Johnson and Z were holding our blue line together we never had to think twice about a second pair. Now Toews is out and those guys are getting 22+ a night, no wonder the goals against doubled 😅 maybe I'm wrong but that smells like carried to me. Thanks for the numbers Sam 🙏
Whoever's buying Sam a beer for that running sheet, I'm in. 22+ a night for a second pair says the depth was thin before Toews even went down.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Sam's sheet tracks with what I've been tallying too, the 22-plus minutes for the second pair since Toews went out is exactly where I'd land the blame. SniperGuy's got a point about the backcheck though, I've watched a couple of those even-strength goals where the forward coasting back was the first mistake and the pair just got hung out after it. I was at the pub for the last one and you could hear the whole section groan every time Makar had to rescue a giveaway. So yes, carried defence, but the forwards own a slice of that doubled GA as well.
Context beats a bare stat.
😂 you lot are arguing about whose fault the leak is while I'm just sitting here asking why the hell the second pair is playing 22+ a night in the first place. Bednar's riding them like a rental mule because he trusts nobody else, that's a coaching confession right there. Remind me of your ROI on blaming the backcheck, SniperGuy 🤡 I'll take the depth-thin-before-Toews side any day.
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Nah FourthLine, blaming Bednar feels too easy tbh 😅 who exactly is he supposed to lean on, the press box? Trade the minutes around and somebody else gets chewed up instead, ah well, nowt to do. Backcheck's a real thing tho SniperGuy, saw forwards floating like it was a boatswain's watch 😤
One love, one side ❤️
Halifax with the "who else is he gonna use" defence 😂 maybe the answer is fewer zone starts from the coffin corner, not vibes and a press box saint. Bednar gets a pass? Get the net outta here 🍿
Halifax with the "who else is he gonna use" defence 😂 maybe the answer is fewer zone starts from the coffin corner, not vibes and a press box saint. Bednar gets a pass? Get the net outta here 🍿
@HarryTillIDie ok that zone start point actually clicked for me 😅 don't laugh guys but I didn't even know that stat existed till this thread. So the coffin corner starts really make the pairing look worse?
New here, soaking it up.
I've got Toews' absence circled in my own tracking sheet and the pattern is ugly: second pair over 22 minutes a night, even-strength goals against basically doubled since the injury. But I keep flip-flopping on where the actual fault sits. Bednar compressing his rotations when your top pair is Makar is defensible with that depth chart, honest to god, yet the zone starts from the deep corners are making it worse than it needs to be. And the backcheck lapses RideOrDie flagged are real, I rewatched two of those goals and a forward gliding in was the first mistake both times.
So maybe the honest answer is that all three takes share the blame and none of them alone closes the leak. Sample's still small-ish too, a handful of games, so I'm not ready to plant a flag. Let's see what the next few even-strength games look like before we convict anyone. 📊
Do the math before you argue.
I've got Toews' absence circled in my own tracking sheet and the pattern is ugly: second pair over 22 minutes a night, even-strength goals against basically doubled since the injury. But I keep flip-flopping on where the…
@TorontoLoyal same sheet situation here and the doubling at evens tracks with the minutes spike, which is exactly the nuance you'd expect when one pair eats everyone's top six. Fault-wise I lean usage, since Bednar had options short of coffin corner starts. Small sample though, a few bad bounces flip that number fast. 📊
Numbers > vibes.
@TorontoLoyal same sheet situation here and the doubling at evens tracks with the minutes spike, which is exactly the nuance you'd expect when one pair eats everyone's top six. Fault-wise I lean usage, since Bednar had o…
@DiehardFan fair point on Bednar having options, but who exactly was he supposed to lean on when the pair is eating top six minutes by necessity? A source close to the room says the usage debate gets settled sooner than folks think 🤫. Usage-adjust or not, somebody's been carrying more than their cheque suggests.
All this stat crunchin about minutes is rough, man. Sounds way more complicated than trying to park a truck in Kelowna. 🤣 Hold my pint.
Came to laugh, stayed for life 🍿
All this data is insane. Can we just get some clean goals already? 🤣🍿
Hold my pint.
@Toque_87 no laughing here, we all start somewhere. Coffin corner starts tank any pairing's numbers, that's the point. I'll believe the "carried" takes once someone adjusts for usage.
Where's the proof?