Makar is carrying this defence so hard that our second pair is
Honest answer? There is no number two, it's Makar then a coin toss π Toews gets called our real 2D by the same lads who were calling him sheltered in December, funny how that works. Wait for the fanboys to pile in and defend that pairing like it won a Cup. And in reality, who's stepping up if Makar has one bad month? Anyone actually got an answer π€‘
Any stat can be bent.
Funny how "coin toss" sounds great until you actually watch the shifts. Toews eats hard minutes, gets the tougher matchups most nights, and the pair still holds its own. Sheltered? Sure, every second pair gets favourable deployment to some degree. That's coaching, not a weakness.
On condition that Makar stays healthy I don't see the panic case. If he goes down for a stretch, yeah, then we learn what Toews really is. Until then calling the whole right side of our defence a rumour is just playing to the pub crowd. I'll believe the doom when I see it on the scoresheet.
Where's the proof?
Toews eats those tough minutes every night and I've watched him kill penalties and shut down top lines without blinking, so call me a fanboy all you want Steve π€ Sheltered my ass, the bloke's been a rock all season. Makar's a god obvi but no one's sliding into panic mode, Toews holds the fort fine πͺπ₯ Ah well, nowt to do but trust the pair.
In the stands since I was a kid.
Remember when Erik Johnson ate 24 minutes a night and we still complained? Toews doing this at his age, sheltered or not, I'll take it π
No fanboy needed mate, the eye test and the matchups both back you up. Funny how the "sheltered" crowd went quiet once spreadsheets started agreeing with you π
Show me your ROI first π
Harry's got the right of it. Watch who Toews lines up against on most nights, it's usually the other team's top unit while Makar sees a bit of everything, so "sheltered" never really fit what I've seen on the shifts. Caveat from me as always: one regular season is a thin sample to crown anyone a true 2D, but if Makar catches a cold for two weeks in April, Toews is the guy I want eating those minutes. Steve can keep his coin toss.
Numbers > vibes.
Remember when Erik Johnson ate 24 minutes a night and we still complained? Toews doing this at his age, sheltered or not, I'll take it π
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Been tracking Toews' deployments in my own spreadsheet since November and both camps have a point, which is probably why this argument never dies. He does draw the tougher matchups most nights, that part is real. The caveat I keep coming back to is the sample around Makar's icetime. If Cale plays 25+ a night like he usually does, Toews is never carrying a true 1D load, so "real number two" and "sheltered" can both be technically true depending on which five-game stretch you pull.
The Victoria point about EJ actually lands for me. Johnson ate big minutes and we grumbled every shift, Toews does the quieter stuff well and we argue about whether it counts. Maybe the honest answer is that the label matters less than the fit next to Makar. I'd wait until we see a stretch where Cale sits a game or two before crowning anybody. π
Do the math before you argue.