Makar is already the best defenceman in franchise history, and yes
Hot take incoming: Makar's already passed Bourque in burgundy and blue, two Norrises and that Cup run beat anything Ray gave us in a Colorado sweater π sure, Ray's Boston years were lovely, but we're talking franchise history here, no? Wait for the fanboys to pile in telling me longevity beats peak. π€‘
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Two Norrises in four full seasons is absurd, I'll give you that, but Victoria's leaving out what Bourque actually did in a Colorado sweater: 110 points in 2000-01 and he captained the defence through that Cup run at 40 years old. Makar's peak is prettier, sure. Show me a decade of it first and I'll hand over the crown willingly.
Hype isn't an argument.
Nah, we aren't talking vintage glory. Makar is operating on a completely different level, a pure dominant force.
In the stands since I was a kid.
I keep a spreadsheet on this exact question, and the age curve is what sells me on Cale. Two Norris trophies inside four full seasons means he arrived at that level basically out of the gate, whereas Ray's best Colorado work, that 110-point season in 2000-01, came at 40 after twenty-plus Boston years built the resume elsewhere. Different shapes of greatness, I'll grant PuckheadDad840 that much.
I could be wrong, but if we're scoring strictly franchise value, the Cup run at Ball Arena tips it for me. Ray captained the defence admirably that spring, yet Makar drove play from the back end as the engine of the whole thing while winning his second Norris in the same stretch. Peak versus longevity is a fair pub fight, and I'd take the pint-throwing crowd's side here. π
I keep my own tables π
Saw Bourque hoist that Cup live at a pub back in '01, pint in hand. But Makar at his age? I'd put my C$50 on Cale already.
The line moves β catch it.
Anyone who reckons vintage points outweigh consistent, elite Norris hardware is just waiting for the fanboys to pile in. Caleβs pure dominance, especially hitting those trophies while contributing so massively, shows a caliber of player that is just different. In reality? Iβd be putting my money on Makar every single night, pure talent always wins out in the long run. ππΈ
Any stat can be bent.
I've got a spreadsheet on this exact matchup too, and here's my honest snag: the samples aren't comparable yet. Bourque gave Colorado five seasons, five hundred-ish games of wear, and that 2000-01 run where a 40-year-old logged heavy minutes every night. Cale's given us two Norrises and a Cup in roughly four full seasons, which is a steeper peak by any measure, but a peak is a snapshot, not a career.
So where does that leave the pub argument? Toque's C$50 says present value beats longevity value, Josh's age curve says the ceiling keeps rising, and the Boston half of Ray's resume only matters if you count franchise history loosely. I genuinely can't close the book on this one. Ask me again in five years, and if Cale's still stacking trophies in burgundy and blue, I'll probably write the verdict myself. Until then, order another round and keep arguing. π
Do the math before you argue.
I keep a spreadsheet on this exact question, and the age curve is what sells me on Cale. Two Norris trophies inside four full seasons means he arrived at that level basically out of the gate, whereas Ray's best Colorado β¦
@Josh_Hoser the age curve angle's fair, but word going round from people close to the room is the org itself still measures Cale against Ray's five years of nightly heavy minutes. Two Norris out the gate is special, no argument. Ask me again after Cale carries a Cup run at 40... oh wait, none of us will be around ππ€«
Word isβ¦ but you didn't hear it here π€«