Jets +1.5 vs the Avs on Oct 7
Anyone actually paying for Jets +1.5 against the team that went 55-16? I'd rather lay the moneyline with Colorado and keep my C$ stake sane than pray Winnipeg's defence hangs around. A 302-203 goal margin vs 231-260 says the cushion gets torched more often than it lands. 💸
The line moves — catch it.
Ran the sample through my spreadsheet before replying, because Toque's framing bugs me slightly. Yes, Colorado's 302-203 against Winnipeg's 231-260 is a chasm, but puck line value isn't about raw goal differential, it's about how often the final margin lands at exactly one. A 99-point gap on the table doesn't tell you the distribution of margins, only the average. Dig a bit deeper: if the Jets' defence actually holds structure in this one, +1.5 cashes on any one-goal game, and favourites of this size push back late in ways that keep it tighter than the season totals suggest.
Caveat on the sample: one October game after a long summer is a small one, and both rosters may look different from last season's numbers.
Do the math before you argue.
So the margin "lands at exactly one" often enough, eh? Funny how that theory always shows up right after someone tops up their account. I put my C$50 where my mouth is, a 55-16 juggernaut against a club that got outscored all season, and you want me buying insurance? Remind me of your ROI, TorontoLoyal? 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.
TorontoLoyal, before I buy the "exactly one margin" theory I'd want the actual frequency, not a vibe from a spreadsheet nobody can check. A 71-goal differential gap between these two usually means empty-netters turn one-goal games into two, which kills +1.5 late. Show me the numbers on how often Winnipeg stayed within one against top-five teams last season, then we'll talk.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Diehard has it right. Empty-netters wreck one-goal tickets with a gap that big. I'd want the exact-one frequency before touching +1.5; shots props look saner to me.
Hype isn't an argument.
Fair challenge from Diehard, and I'll cop to it, my spreadsheet tracks margin-of-victory buckets for teams I follow, but I can't quote you an exact-one frequency for this specific matchup off the top of my head, so treat that as theory until we see October data.
Here's what I would say though, and it's the piece nobody's weighing yet: schedule context. Winnipeg hosts Anaheim on the 10th and Minnesota on the 14th before this one's neighbourhood games, while Colorado has a Dallas back-to-back around the 14th-15th plus Pittsburgh on the 17th. When the Avs are mid-road stretch with a heavy forward workload, you sometimes get a leading team sitting on a 4-2 and the Jets pulling the goalie-in-reverse drama that keeps things at two rather than three. Empty-netters do kill +1.5 late, no argument, but which version of Colorado shows up matters for whether we're even talking a two-goal game or a five-goal blowout.
Context beats a bare stat.
At least RideOrDie admits the spreadsheet can't answer the actual question, which is more than most do in here. I'll believe the "exactly one" frequency when someone posts it, though, show me the numbers for a team with a -29 goal differential facing one at +99, and we'll talk.
My caveat: even if the one-goal rate holds up, that gap in finishing (55-16 vs 35-35) means Colorado pulls goalies late and Winnipeg's defence gets pinned. Empty-netter risk is real. Personally I stopped touching +1.5 in these mismatch spots after getting burned a couple seasons back, a C$20 ticket dying because of an uncontested tap-in at 19:58 teaches you something. Shots props on Winnipeg's still-relevant forwards look like the saner angle to me too.
Where's the proof?
@Harry_RinkRat1993 fair point, though a -29 vs +99 gap is such an outlier that historical buckets barely mean anything anyway, context matters here more than usual. I keep margins for teams I follow too and even my own sample is too thin for one-goal games against top-heavy sides. Give me a season of Winnipeg results against playoff-calibre Central teams and then the puck line talk means something. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Agreed, I don't buy +1.5 at that talent gap either, took Colorado moneyline here last time and it landed easy. Shots prop on a Jet skater looks like the better value to me. 💸
Fair challenge from Diehard, and I'll cop to it, my spreadsheet tracks margin-of-victory buckets for teams I follow, but I can't quote you an exact-one frequency for this specific matchup off the top of my head, so treat…
The thing about those victory bucket spreadsheets is that even if the data point exists, the relevance of a small sample size often gets overlooked. I'd argue you need context on how frequently that specific difference in quality shows up, not just the raw frequency for the matchup. It’s a very thin sample when you’re talking about a difference that hinges on one goal, so treat the theoretical frequency with extreme skepticism.
I keep my own tables 📊
The thing about those victory bucket spreadsheets is that even if the data point exists, the relevance of a small sample size often gets overlooked. I'd argue you need context on how frequently that specific difference i…
This. Word going round is the room's already fading theJets side anyway 😏 small samples lie, context doesn't