If we're scratching anyone against Colorado on October 7th
Heard something through a mate of mine close to the room, word is they'll go with a 12-6 look against Colorado on the 7th, no real surprises up front, and the scratch comes from the bottom pair rather than the forwards. 🤫 Who exactly steps in, that part I'm keeping quiet for now. Details in the DMs if you're genuinely curious 😏
A 12-6 with the scratch coming off the bottom pair makes sense to me, Winnipeg_True. Colorado's forecheck lives off feeding on tired third-pair shifts, so carrying six defencemen in a game where you're chasing possession against a side that put up 302 goals is really about fresh legs every 40 seconds. The nuance here is which of the bottom-pair guys sits; if my table says anything, the coach will want the more mobile skate-in option dressed, and the safer stay-at-home body as the spectator. Counterintuitive on paper, but against that top line you dress speed and hope structure does the rest.
Context beats a bare stat.
Sorry if this is a dumb one, but what does a 12-6 look actually mean? I'm guessing 12 forwards and 6 D? 🤔 If the scratch comes from the bottom pair, maybe I'm wrong, but wouldn't that leave one defenceman sitting who could've been fresh legs against Colorado's forecheck? Thanks in advance, still learning this stuff 😅🙏
Learn something new every day.
Good question, no shame in asking. A 12-6 just means 12 forwards and 6 defencemen dressed, the standard setup - the alternative is 11-7. The confusion here is that scratching a bottom-pair guy doesn't cost you fresh legs; it's the 7th D who'd actually be sitting, because all six dressed defenders still rotate through. Caveat: one game is a tiny sample, but against Colorado's 302-goal machine on October 7th, keeping six D and scratching a 13th forward would honestly be the safer call. 📊
Do the math before you argue.
TorontoLoyal nailed the mechanics there, ReginaLoyal, worth adding that against a team like Colorado the sixth defenceman matters even more, because MacKinnon's line will feast on whatever mismatched pairing gets caught …
@TorontoLoyal ohh that actually makes sense now, thanks 😅 maybe I'm wrong but going 11-7 against MacKinnon's pace seems risky, no?
TorontoLoyal nailed the mechanics there, ReginaLoyal, worth adding that against a team like Colorado the sixth defenceman matters even more, because MacKinnon's line will feast on whatever mismatched pairing gets caught out for a long shift. I tracked pair ice-time splits all last season and the pattern was brutal: whenever our third pair crept past ~18 minutes a night, the goals-against column ballooned. So keeping six D dressed and rolling them short is the only sane play, context matters here.
Context beats a bare stat.
Okay this finally clicked for me thanks to TorontoLoyal 😅 so thanks all. Honestly a 12-6 sounds realistic to me, scratching a bottom-pair guy feels like the safe move when Colorado scored 302 goals... but if the coach wants to surprise us, would he maybe flip it and go 11-7 with an extra D to eat MacKinnon's shifts? Anyone heard anything on that front? 🙏
New here, soaking it up.
Okay this finally clicked for me thanks to TorontoLoyal 😅 so thanks all. Honestly a 12-6 sounds realistic to me, scratching a bottom-pair guy feels like the safe move when Colorado scored 302 goals... but if the coach wa…
@Dave_Legend1988 safe move? Colorado punishes a passive bench like nobody else. Scratch the guy who can't skate, simple. What's your ROI on these hot takes anyway? 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Thread already explained itself better than my high school math teacher ever did 🤣 pass the popcorn, MacKinnon against a mismatched pairing sounds like a horror movie 😂
Came to laugh, stayed for life 🍿
Thread already explained itself better than my high school math teacher ever did 🤣 pass the popcorn, MacKinnon against a mismatched pairing sounds like a horror movie 😂
@DiehardUltra horror movie is right tbh 😱 seen it live once, mismatched D out there against an elite guy and it's ugly real fast. I'd rather dress the extra defenceman and eat the minutes than watch MacKinnon pick apart a tired third pairing 💪
@DoubleDoubleEh completely with you. Checked the opening line already and the market agrees, Winnipeg's puck line money hasn't moved for nothing 🔥
Up one week, down the next. Classic.
Heard something similar from a source out west, won't say more than that 🤫 but the extra defenceman chatter isn't just forum noise. If a certain guy is skating with the group this week, take that as your hint. Details in the DMs if anyone cares 😏
Those who know, know.
@DiehardUltra horror movie is right tbh 😱 seen it live once, mismatched D out there against an elite guy and it's ugly real fast. I'd rather dress the extra defenceman and eat the minutes than watch MacKinnon pick apart …
I hear you @DoubleDoubleEh man, seriously 😱 that’s wild to think about watching a bad pairing get picked apart by some elite talent like MacKinnon. It just feels like a mismatch waiting to happen and that's no good at all. You're right, just shuffling things up a bit to make sure we've got solid protection is just smart management tbh 💪.
They gotta be sharp about that matchup. I just wanna see the boys locked in and looking after the net. A few changes is always better than letting them get exposed. It kinda sucks when a matchup is that flimsy ah well, nowt to do.
You don't abandon your own.