Honest question, fam: is it finally time to retire Sid's number
Saw a guy at the pub Friday in a "Crosby 87 Hall of Fame" jersey already, half our table toasted him and the rest nearly chucked their poutine π Honestly? Hang the banner now, the man's earned it and waiting just feeds the superstition crowd. Anyone seriously thinking a banner night jinxes Sid is the same type who blames the puck line for losing their parlay π€‘
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Banner before he retires? I'll believe it when he signs that last contract. Guy in the jersey is just early, not right.
Where's the proof?
Three Cups sitting there, Harry. No jinx retires number 87, the man does. π Hang it whenever the org pleases.
Context beats a bare stat.
Remember watching Lemieux's banner go up and half my atom team crying in the stands, so trust me, the rafters wait for nobody π Sid's earned it ten times over with those three Cups, hang it whenever. Superstition? The Habs retired legends mid-legacy for years and nobody cursed them. Get his up and let him keep adding to the rΓ©sumΓ©, ah well, nowt to do but cheer π₯πͺ
In the stands since I was a kid.
Puckhead nails it with the Lemieux memory, that's exactly the one I was going to bring up. I was a kid when Mario's banner went up and he hadn't even finished his story yet, nobody in the building thought it cursed anything. And the Habs comparison holds up too, they retired legends while legends were still breathing and kept winning anyway.
My one caveat, and I keep a running sheet on this stuff, is that banner-before-retirement cases are a small sample across the league, so you can't prove the jinx either way. Context matters. That said, Sid has three Cups and 87 is untouchable regardless of what the last contract looks like. If the org hangs it early, I'll toast the guy in that pub jersey myself. Small sample or not, some things you just know.
Do the math before you argue.
Nah hang on, Lemieux's banner went up when Mario basically couldn't play anymore, Sid's still our best skater most nights π€ Hang it now and what, he watches his own number in the rafters for five more years? Feels backwards to me. And CalgaryEh take it easy, some of us are just superstitious, I spilled a full beer at the pub when the guy in that 87 HOF jersey sat down π€¬
You don't abandon your own.
Counter-example? Teemu Selanne had his banner up while still skating warmups in Anaheim, nobody blinked π Sid watching his own number for five years sounds like a flex to me π€£
Only serious one here β barely.
Saw that Selanne point and it holds up, the Ducks hung his banner in 2018 while he still had a season left on his contract. Honestly watching your own number for a few years is a flex, not a curse. Jinxing? That's what people say when they've got money on the puck line and need an excuse.
Hype isn't an argument.
Funny how both the Selanne case and Mario's banner kind of argue for opposite answers and nobody's wrong, eh? Anaheim did it while Teemu still had games left and it was a celebration, but Sid's a different animal, still driving our top line most nights. I keep my table open on this one until he says something himself, one way or the other.
Context beats a bare stat.
@RideOrDie4Life this. Sid's still giving'r every shift, why rush the banner? Hang it when he's actually done, let him enjoy it then π₯
Yeah I'm with Vancouver99 on this tbh, Sid's still THE guy out there every night π§ hang it when he's actually done, not while he's giving'r on the top line
One love, one side β€οΈ