Honest debate, fam: is it finally time to hang the legends' jerseys
Watched Sid coast through that last home stand and honestly the legs are gone. Half the pub wants one more playoff lap, the other half already picked out rafter space, and I'm with the rafter crowd 😏. Retire 87 and 71 while anyone still cares, then rebuild for real. Sure thing, mate, keep Sully's system limping into another wildcard exit 🤡💸
Watched Sid coast through that last home stand and honestly the legs are gone. Half the pub wants one more playoff lap, the other half already picked out rafter space, and I'm with the rafter crowd 😏. Retire 87 and 71 wh…
Coasting? He was on the ice more than any forward in that stand. Show me the legs-gone numbers before we start picking rafter space, John.
Hype isn't an argument.
PuckheadDad has a point, John. You watched one home stand and called the legs gone, that's a tiny sample and you know how I feel about tiny samples 📊. The guy logging the most forward minutes in that stretch is usually the guy the coach trusts to eat those minutes, which is the opposite of coasting. Context matters here.
Where I land is somewhere between you and Calgary. Nobody's saying Sid doesn't get his ceremony, 87 goes in the rafters the moment it's eligible and nobody in this pub argues otherwise. The real question is whether you commit cap and roster around one more lap or start moving pieces now, and honestly I'd rather see the front office treat this season as an evaluation window than a fire sale. But retired numbers and a rebuild aren't the same decision, we can retire 87 and 71 whenever the time comes without pretending the sky falls if we add one more playoff push first.
Do the math before you argue.
Seen this movie before, boys. Back in my day we watched Mario limp through his last laps too, and nobody was screaming to hang the jersey while he could still Dangle. Sid's earned the right to decide when the rafter comes calling, and I'd take one more playoff push over a rebuild any spring 😉
Remember when the grass was greener 🌱
Funny how everyone arguing samples and minutes forgot the actual product on the ice, eh. Half those "trusted minutes" were spent gliding while the play died in the corner, and if Coach trusts him that much, why's the offence running through everybody else? Retire the number when he says he's done, sure thing mate, but don't pretend one more lap beats drafting an actual pipeline 🤡💸. What's the plan when Sid's gone mid-rebuild anyway, pray?
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Victoria, I'll give you this much: the corner play dying down low has bothered me too, and I keep my own sheets every game, so I'm not defending on vibes. But "offence runs through everybody else" cuts both ways. A coach spreads looks when defences sell out on one guy every shift, which opens the ice for whoever's beside him. That's a different read than decline.
PoutineTrue's Mario comparison is the one that keeps landing for me, honestly. Nobody in this thread can point to a date where the legs were suddenly gone, same as nobody could back then. My pub crowd splits the same way yours does, and maybe that split is the honest answer. One more spring tells us more than any home stand stretch will, so I'm keeping both columns open in my table until the games force my hand 📊
Context beats a bare stat.