Honest debate, Bolts family
Three straight first-round outs after back-to-back Cups and some of you still want a fourth lap with Coop? π I watched the last exit with my own eyes at the pub, same story, same "trust the process" chant by the second intermission. Sure thing mate, keep the faith and tell me your ROI on patience so far π€‘πΈ
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Three straight first-round outs after back-to-back Cups and some of you still want a fourth lap with Coop? π I watched the last exit with my own eyes at the pub, same story, same "trust the process" chant by the second iβ¦
Sitting in the pub chanting isn't evidence either, Vic. Show me the numbers that say a coach is the problem when the roster has been gutted by cap math and injuries every spring. Cooper has two Cups on the shelf, I'd fire him off three first-round exits if someone could name the coach who does better with this group. Not convinced anyone can.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Ride with Coops, no question πͺπ₯ The bloke got us two Cups back to back, you don't toss that over a couple of gutted rosters and bad injury luck in April. Vic you were chanting right along with the rest of us last spring, don't act all high and mighty now π Give him one more run with a healthy lineup, then we talk. Ah well, nowt to do but believe π
In the stands since I was a kid.
Diehard has a point about cap math, but context matters here. I keep my own tables every spring, and even with a gutted roster the special teams were sliding in all three exits, which is the one thing a coach controls regardless of injuries. Small sample caveat, three playoffs is three playoffs, but when your power play goes cold two Aprils in a row you dig a bit deeper than "bad luck". I'd give Coops one more run with a healthy blue line before anyone starts pouring the farewell pint. π
Do the math before you argue.
@TorontoLoyal fair point but injuries gutted that room, hard to run a PP when your shooters are all in the press box π€ giving Coop one more year tbh π₯
In the stands since I was a kid.
I've been on this ride since the Cup runs, watched Game 6s at the pub until last call, and here's the thing I keep circling back to: every dynasty window in this league has a shelf life, and the question is never whether it ends, it's whether you admit it ended before the guy behind the bench does. TorontoLoyal's tables echo what mine show too, the special teams slide across those three exits is real, but I'd add a caveat about the sample: three springs with shredded blue lines and a cap crunch is a small dataset to hang a coach on.
Back when we won back-to-back, Cooper got a top-heavy roster and the ping pong balls bounced our way in OT more than once. Now he gets a thinner lineup every April. Fair? Not entirely. Relevant? Absolutely. I say one more run, but with conditions: if the power play goes flat again in round one, the conversation changes for me personally.
Numbers > vibes.
TorontoLoyal's tables match what I've been scribbling down myself, special teams slipping in all three exits is the one stat that keeps me up at night. I could be wrong, but I lean with DiehardFan on the shelf life thing, though I'd give Cooper one more run if the power play gets fixed by December. My old man and I have watched every April exit together at the same corner booth, and even he said after the last one that the same story third time around hurts more than the losses themselves.
I keep my own tables π
Funny how Josh and I basically keep the same scribbles, eh. The special teams slide across all three exits is the one column in my spring tables that never recovers, and a power play is the one lever a coach holds even when the roster is gutted. So I can live with one more run, but only with a real checkpoint, say if the man advantage is still drifting by December you thank him properly and move on. What I can't sign off on is "trust the process" as a pub chant with no expiry date on it. Dynasty windows close, and the honest question is whether we'd know a faded window if we saw one. I'll keep my tables open and my mind half-open too. π
Context beats a bare stat.