Kucherov in his prime is still the best player this franchise has
Say Kooch and watch half the pub table flip like you insulted someone's mum π every pregame pint in Tampa someone brings up Stamkos and the bubble Cup debate starts all over again. Sticky won us two more Cups from that 2020 run, and in reality? Best player this franchise has ever dressed, not even close. Fight me at the pub, first round's on you π»π
Show me your ROI first π
Say Kooch and watch half the pub table flip like you insulted someone's mum π every pregame pint in Tampa someone brings up Stamkos and the bubble Cup debate starts all over again. Sticky won us two more Cups from that 2β¦
Sat at that table in Tampa two seasons back, heard the whole Stamkos vs Kooch argument go three rounds while the wings went cold. The Stamkos side always leans on loyalty and the 2020 banner, but loyalty is a feeling, Kucherov's case is on the scoresheet every April. Show me the numbers and it's not close: the points, the pace, the way entire defensive schemes got built around stopping him.
On the bubble Cup thing, I'll push back the other way. Four rounds against real lineups is four rounds. If anything that run proved Kooch was the engine, Stammer was sidelined for most of it and they still went through. Glad we got both, but if you're picking one player at his peak for a game seven, I'm handing the puck to 86 and buying the next round myself.
Hype isn't an argument.
Kooch every night of the week π₯ the scoresheet don't lie, Stamkos gets the banner talk 'cause of his heart... both matter but 86 is different πͺ
In the stands since I was a kid.
Been keeping my own tables on this for years, and the April scoresheet settles it. Kooch by a mile. The bubble Cup counts too, banners don't have asterisks. π
I keep my own tables π
been watching this franchise since the empty seats in the old days, and i'll tell you young fellas something. we argued Lecavalier vs St. Louis the same way at the pub, two mugs deep, nobody ever won. kooch in his prime is the best this club's seen, banners included, bubble or no bubble π
Watch as long as I have and you'll get it.
Jack's right, and anyone who sat through Vinny vs Marty knows how these debates die of old age. I'll take Kooch too, only caveat being I want three more healthy Aprils from him before I ink it, sample size on prime years matters. Fought this exact fight with my brother-in-law at a pregame pint, he's Leafs Nation oddly enough, and even he conceded the April scoresheet point, which is how you know it's settled π
Context beats a bare stat.
Funny thing is I sat at that exact table in Tampa two springs back, and the Stamkos guy didn't flip until somebody whispered "bubble". Then all hell broke loose over a second pint π
I keep my own tables on this club like some of you know, and here's where I land after a decade of cells and columns: Kooch's peak is the highest we've ever seen, the 2020 run included, and I count it fully because they beat whoever was put in front of them. But Sam's got a point about prime years. Vinny vs Marty taught us that the argument outlives the players. Maybe the honest answer is 86 owns the ceiling, 91 owns the heartbeat, and the pub stays split forever. Works for me, keeps the pints interesting.
Do the math before you argue.