Are we clinging to the glory days?
Honest question for the room: what exactly are we protecting here? A playoff spot we're going to lose in round one anyway? The trade deadline told me everything I needed to know about this front office, patching leaks on a boat that's already taking on water instead of selling high while anyone still wants our veterans.
I'd rather eat two ugly seasons and draft properly than keep tricking myself into believing one more short-term fix turns this around. Half of you will wait for the fanboys to pile in before admitting the core era is done. What's your timeline then, another three years of "one more run"? 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Honest question for the room: what exactly are we protecting here? A playoff spot we're going to lose in round one anyway? The trade deadline told me everything I needed to know about this front office, patching leaks on…
Selling who exactly? Nobody's clearing a first for a 35-year-old winger. Show me the numbers on what a fire sale actually returns before calling the boat sunk.
Hype isn't an argument.
Nah, I'm with PuckheadDad on this one 🔥 Nobody's giving us a haul for the vets right now, that's just how the market works. You sell when value's there, and the returns at this deadline would've been pocket change and futures lottery tickets... for what exactly?
Heart says it all tbh. Those guys bled for two Cups, you don't toss them out for a handful of thirds just to look "serious" about a rebuild 😤 We've seen Canadian teams tear it all down and wander the desert for a decade, nah thanks. Wrong window talk in June, keep the seats loud through thick and thin 💪🙌
In the stands since I was a kid.
PuckheadDad asked for numbers on a fire sale, so I'll answer honestly: there aren't any good ones to show. That's sort of the point Victoria is missing. When a 35-year-old winger's market is second and third round picks at best, holding him wasn't sentimental, it was just reading the room.
Where I'll push back slightly on Josh is "sell when value's there." The nuance here is you sell when value is there OR when the decline curve is obvious, and for this core it's been obvious for a couple seasons now. My own spreadsheet has the return on window shrinking every year, and the deadline only confirmed the market knows it too. So the deadline didn't choose short-term over long-term, the market made that call for us. The real question is whether we cash out this summer before the returns get even thinner, because they will. Watch what Toronto paid at their deadline the last few years for rental wingers and tell me that's a market you wait on. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
been through a couple of these rebuilds myself, season tickets since the old days when half this roster was on waitlists nobody wanted. here's the thing nobody my age forgets: tear-down years look great on paper until you're six seasons deep watching lottery balls bounce wrong. i sat through those drafts, kiddos, the "futures" mostly stayed futures.
so yeah, rideordie has it right, the market for our vets at the deadline was a couple mid-round picks and a pat on the back. hold, keep selling hope cheap some other time. ride or die with the boys at the pub and see where spring takes us 😉
Watch as long as I have and you'll get it.
Context matters here, and Jack's lottery-ball warning is the part of this thread I keep coming back to. A deadline sale when every buyer knows you're desperate gets you futures lottery tickets, as Josh put it, so holding the vets reads as patience rather than denial. Whether that patience turns into an actual plan or just another short-term patch, that's the question I can't answer yet, and I don't think anyone here honestly can. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.