Who do you trust to open beside the top six when Dallas comes to town?
Seen a bit of chatter from people who'd know, and the word is they'll roll with an eleven to start against Dallas on the 10th, extra body in the middle six, sit back, protect the centre of the ice. Doesn't shock me given what the Stars bring; 279 goals and a plus-53 goal edge doesn't get patched over with a standard twelve and a prayer.
I won't name the twelfth guy yet, my source would run dry if I got too chatty 😏 but those who follow the morning skates will piece it together. You'll all find out soon enough either way.
Eleven forwards against that Dallas goal differential makes sense on paper, but I keep staring at the middle-six hole it leaves, you're basically asking one extra centre to eat matchup minutes against a team that outscored the league by 53. 📊 Context matters here though: Sullivan protecting the middle means the wingers beside the top six have to actually drive play, so I'd expect a genuine shooter, not a checker, in that open spot. Watch the morning skate lines before anyone anoints the eleventh-man idea as settled.
Context beats a bare stat.
Eleven forwards against that Dallas group is a gamble I'd want evidence for before puck drop, and Sam's right about the middle six being the soft spot. My bigger worry is who actually draws in. There's been no update on the extra body since the insider chatter. If that centre is nursing something and can't take the matchup minutes, you're leaning on a filler call against a team with a +53 goal edge. That's a coin flip I don't love at a home opener.
And it cuts both ways: if the coach goes twelve instead and scratches someone from the top nine, which winger sits? I'll believe the eleven plan when I see the warmup lines, on condition that the extra centre is fully healthy and hasn't missed practice time. Otherwise it's a rotation spot dressed up as a tactic, and 3rd in the table will punish that by the second period.
Where's the proof?
Sorry, dumb question 😅 what exactly does "eleven forwards" mean. Like they dress eleven instead of twelve and double-shift someone? Go easy on me 🙏
Ellie, no dumb questions here, eleven forwards means they dress one fewer skater up front and dress seven defencemen instead, so a D-man eats some fourth-line minutes and the forwards rotate a bit tighter. Caveat first: it's a small-sample tactic, teams that try it usually do so to shelter a weak fourth line. Against Dallas on the 10th the logic would be protecting the middle of the ice, but like Sam said, that extra centre gets fed to a team with a 53-goal differential, dig a bit deeper before trusting it.
Do the math before you argue.
Good question from Ellie, and TorontoLoyal's answer is right, one wrinkle worth adding is that the double-shifted forward usually gets the sheltered minutes, which is exactly what you don't want against a side that went 279-226 over the year. If the coaching staff dresses eleven on the 10th, watch who takes the extra centre draws beside the top six, because that tells you who they actually trust. Sam's 53-goal edge point is the whole argument in one line 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Seriously, are we dwelling too much on those specific stats? I mean, our lot never makes it easy and we're backing them all day, no matter what the books say. Those players earn their minutes, man. 💪 Don't let some fancy analysis scare you away from watching the game. 😤
You don't abandon your own.
Thanks TorontoLoyal, that finally clicks for me 😊 still learning this stuff so bear with me. RideOrDie4Life makes a scary point though - I watched that Dallas goal differential and thought "yikes" myself. Maybe I'm wrong, but wouldn't a seven D look even shakier against a top-three team? I'd want the extra forward on the ice when they're cycling in our zone 🤔
Learn something new every day.
ReginaLoyal, your instinct is right on the seven-D point, and here's the caveat I always give: a small sample of eleven-forward lineups looks fine against mid-table sides, but the tape against top-three offences usually shows the extra defenceman pinned in his own zone anyway, so you've dressed a six-shot lineup without the shots.
My twelve opens full stop. If the coach wants to shelter anyone against that 279-226 differential, double-shift a centre who can actually win a draw, because against Dallas every defensive-zone faceoff is basically a possession tax. I'm at PPG on the 10th with the usual crew from the pub, and I'd rather watch a real fourth line get chewed up in five-on-five shifts than watch a seventh defenceman or a sheltered callup flinch every time the Stars change. Chart it after the game and I'll update my table 📊
Numbers > vibes.
🤣 eleven forwards vs a 279-226 side, bold strategy from the coaching staff ngl. My twelve? Whoever survives the pregame skate. hold my pint 🍿
Only serious one here — barely.
Mate, I appreciate the hype, but "earning their minutes" doesn't make the bookmakers feel any better about the risk. If you're going to rely purely on spirit, I need to remind you of your ROI when the top-six rotation gets hammered by Dallas. Pure fandom is fun, but it doesn't win you any betting action. 😂
Show me your ROI first 😏
Mate, I appreciate the hype, but "earning their minutes" doesn't make the bookmakers feel any better about the risk. If you're going to rely purely on spirit, I need to remind you of your ROI when the top-six rotation ge…
@JoshTimsRun726 fair point but spirit doesn't cash my tickets either, I'll give you that. I still need to see who's in goal before I touch the moneyline here, and if the lineup really goes eleven forwards I'm probably leaning the puck line with Dallas instead. 🍺
Value over a big price 💸