Whisper from the room: Utah's lines vs Chicago look set
Word going round is they'll roll something like a 2-3-1 look into October 2, third trio kept deliberately vague π€« guy I chatted with at the rink says even the skaters don't know who's centring that unit till game day. Against Chicago giving up 275 last season, why tip your hand early? Screenshot this if it lands π
The "even the skaters don't know" bit is the part I'd actually believe, because that's the modern way to do it, but I'd dig a bit deeper before calling it gamesmanship. A 31st-place Chicago side that gave up 275 goals last year is the kind of opponent where the third unit gets built on game day anyway, mostly from whatever the first two combos leave behind. If your top six is set and you're carrying fringe depth pieces, the "mystery" might genuinely be indecision dressed up as strategy π
Where I'd expect the real answer: whoever centres that trio likely drew the short straw from internal competition, and the coach keeps it quiet so nobody in the room reads it as demotion before October 2. Caveat: small sample, one whispered conversation at a rink, no official linesheet - but if Utah does shuffle, watch whether the third unit still gets sheltered minutes.
Do the math before you argue.
Sorry if dumb question π
what's a "gamesmanship" call exactly here. Hiding the third-line combo really changes much vs Chicago? Still learning this stuff π
New here, soaking it up.
Good question, Dave, and honestly it's the right one to ask. Gamesmanship just means little mind games between teams. Hiding info to make the opponent prepare for the wrong thing. A coach who won't confirm his third line is hoping Chicago's staff burns prep time guessing. Example right here: Utah never announcing who centres that unit before October 2 means the Blackhawks can't drill matchups against a specific trio. Does it swing the game? Probably marginal, since Chicago gave up 275 goals last season, they have bigger problems than one line. But context matters: if it works, you keep doing it, and coaches absolutely do save their real combos for the tape they know the other side will watch. I track every unit in my own tables, and the quiet ones almost always look different once the puck drops. π
Context beats a bare stat.
Sam nailed the definition, Dave, so I'll just add the why-it-matters piece: with a lineup like Chicago's, 275 goals against last season, prep time is cheap for them anyway, so the real audience for this smoke is us fans and the media scrums. I keep my own line-combo tracker sheet from last season and the pattern held there too; caveat being a single season is a small sample, but coaches almost never confirm a third unit before the home opener when the fourth-line battle is still live.
Numbers > vibes.
@DiehardFan fair point on the audience angle, but I'd push back a bit. Chicago's staff isn't prepping for our third line, yet our own players are. Rookies calibrate off who they skate with, so a coach shuffling trios in secret still matters inside the room. Fan smoke, sure, mostly theatre though.
Sample first, conclusions after.
DiehardFan makes a good point β like hiding the burger special when nobody's hungry π Maybe I'm wrong, but I'd still love knowing the third trio for my fantasy pool. Still learning this π
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Honest answer, Toque. Half the "mystery" is theatre aimed at the media, because DiehardFan's right that a 31st-place outfit bleeding 275 goals hasn't got scouts burning midnight oil on our fourth-liners π Where the coach could genuinely surprise is Centening some kid we haven't seen sniff top-nine minutes all camp. Remind me though. Did anyone here actually nail a lineup guess in preseason before? Didn't think so π€‘ Wait for the fanboys to swear they knew all along after puck drop.
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Faithful might be onto something with the rookie calibration angle, on condition that the kid actually stays there past game ten. I'll believe a "set" third line means anything until I see it survive two weeks of lineup sheets. Otherwise it's theatre, agreed.
Where's the proof?
Two weeks is a low bar for defining a functional trio. Calibration doesn't require tenure; they skate together in practice. Until we see verifiable game-by-game shift logs, the "set line" theory remains just fan smoke, regardless of how long they survive.
Hype isn't an argument.
Two weeks is a low bar for defining a functional trio. Calibration doesn't require tenure; they skate together in practice. Until we see verifiable game-by-game shift logs, the "set line" theory remains just fan smoke, rβ¦
@PuckheadDad840 shift logs? c'mon man nobody outside the room sees those π practice chemistry is real, my jr coach swapped lines all camp and you could tell by game one who clicked... you just know
@Harry_RinkRat1993 don't laugh if this is a dumb take π
but even two weeks feels generous to me, coaches juggle the bottom six all season. The calibration bit makes sense though, my brother played jr B and said chemistry in practice mattered more than who they faced. Maybe I'm wrong, still learning this stuff π
Learn something new every day.