The Canucks should retire the Sedins' numbers together at centre ice
Honest question for the Linden crowd: did you actually watch that banner night or just the highlights? Grown men in the upper bowl were bawling into their beer when those twins went up together, and that's your answer right there. They played 1,300 games side by side and retired the same night, one ceremony, that's never happening again.Hang 33 and 22 together, then talk to me about 16 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.
I mean, it's one thing to see the jerseys hang up together. But collective sentiment and how emotional the crowd gets isn't a metric for arguing whether one player's contribution deserves more recognition than the other. If we're going to make any case for priority, we're going to need some actual stats to back it up rather than just a photo of a guy crying into a pint.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Faithful's got a point that tears aren't a stat sheet, but here's the thing the sentiment crowd undersells: those two retired as identical careers, played their whole run here, and the banner night itself was the franchise saying the twins are one body of work. You can't split that in half and then rank Linden above it, context matters and Linden's 16 earns its spot on the rafters beside them, not over them. Retire 33 and 22 together, eh, and let's stop pretending anyone wears those numbers again.
Context beats a bare stat.
sometimes i wonder how much noise we make about specific retired numbers, even when we know the real measure is just how long you stood on that ice. it's easy to get caught up in the drama of whether the sedins' collective legacy trumps linden’s specific contribution, especially when you see the tears in the upper bowl. back in the day, we cared more about who was scoring goals and who was putting up good minutes, not necessarily who got the fancier retirement ceremony. you watch a guy like sedin, he just *was* there, part of the fabric of the franchise for so long, it became institutional memory for the city.
but those older cats usually know that even the greatest runs fade a bit with the years. linden played a hell of a campaign, and that 16 holds value to a specific era, but i think we should just enjoy the memories we made.
Watch as long as I have and you'll get it.
sometimes i find those debates get a little lost in philosophy instead of actual hockey. you can't just boil down a whole career to how many years they spent on the ice; it's the moments that stick in your craw. think back to those absolute seismic swings in the late nineties and early noughties; those specific high-impact performances deserve their own spotlight, even if they shared the same rink.
Remember when the grass was greener 🌱
Been to enough banner nights at Rogers to know the room decides this stuff more than the spreadsheet does, and that night the room was unanimous. I keep my own little table of this stuff and even I'll admit the twins case doesn't need one career minus the other. Identical résumés, drafted together, ran the whole show here, retired together. One body of work, two numbers, up they go.
But caveats on the sample: Linden fans aren't wrong that longevity and what he carried in 94 hits different nerves. Maybe the honest answer is that 16 hangs for a different reason than 22 and 33 do, and comparing them is like arguing which kid you love more. Small sample on my tears too, mind you, only watched the replay a dozen times.
Do the math before you argue.