Sell at the deadline or keep fighting from 26th, Jets fans?
Word going round the dressing room isn't pretty, and minus-29 tells you plenty π 26th with 82 points, and October opens with Pittsburgh away then Colorado and Minnesota at Canada Life Centre. Sell, I say. Details in the DMs for those who know π€«
"Dressing room word" from an anonymous insider, that's your evidence? Show me the numbers. Minus-29 over a full season is a real problem, sure, and 26th is 26th. But selling because October looks nasty on paper, before a single one of those five games has been played, is lazy reasoning dressed up as analysis.
Pittsburgh away, then Colorado, Minnesota and Anaheim at Canada Life Centre. If this roster goes 1-4 there, fine, I'll listen to a fire sale argument. If they steal a couple, the "sell" crowd will look silly by Remembrance Day. I'll believe it when I see it, not because someone's DMs told them so.
Where's the proof?
Keep fighting tbh. October home stand vs Colorado and Minnesota will tell us plenty before anyone trades anyone π₯ backing them all day
One love, one side β€οΈ
How can you really just say 'keep fighting' when you've been battling with a minus-29 goal difference for 82 games? Seeing Colorado and Minnesota in October is nice, sure, but those single home series don't magically undo the fact the team is currently 26th in the league standings. We need tangible systemic change, not just a hopeful October stretch.
Context beats a bare stat.
Harry's got the right instinct but stopped halfway. The numbers he asked for are already sitting there: 35 wins, 35 losses, 231 goals for and 260 against over 82 games. That's a middling team with a leaky defence, not a playoff sleeper. One decent home stretch against Colorado and Minnesota in October doesn't rewrite a full season of that. Sell while the returns are something.
Hype isn't an argument.
PuckheadDad summed it up well, though I'd add one caveat before we all wave the white flag. Yes, 35-35 with a minus-29 over 82 games is a fair sample, no small-number fluke, and I keep my own spreadsheet on this club so I've stared at those 260 against plenty. But the sell-vs-keep question usually gets answered by the return, and selling in October rarely gets you full value. Buyers pay deadline prices. My worry is different: that first stretch, Pittsburgh away then Colorado and Minnesota at Canada Life Centre, could bury the bedrock morale by Thanksgiving. I was at the home opener two seasons back when the crowd turned early, and the rink felt like a morgue by the second period. So if they stumble out of the gate, sure, sell. If they steal a couple of those, hold and reassess in December π
Do the math before you argue.
TorontoLoyal keeps a spreadsheet, cute. Meanwhile the schedule itself argues for selling: Pittsburgh away, then Colorado, Minnesota and Anaheim at Canada Life Centre in the first week and a half of October. A 26th-place team at minus-29 staring at that run? I'd rather be a seller with real assets than "keep fighting" into another 35-35 season.
Sample first, conclusions after.
TorontoLoyal is closest to right, and I say that as a guy with my own workbook open right now. 82 games of minus-29 is a real sample, no arguing that. But my caveat before anyone torches the roster: depends how you count it. A chunk of those 260 against came in stretches where the skaters couldn't buy a goal, so the defensive number and the roster quality aren't the same problem. Still, 26th is 26th.
My personal wrinkle: I've had October 7 circled since the schedule dropped, Colorado at Canada Life Centre, dad's flying in from Thunder Bay for it. I'd love to walk in with a contender. If they're sitting there after those first five games the way they finished last year, sell, and sell early, because a soft rebuild drags on for years. π
Numbers > vibes.
Honestly I'd take the October points now before that Avalanche game gets ugly. Sell. Anyone holding this roster in the parlay pool wants their head checked π€‘πΈ
Here to argue, not to nod along.
DiehardFan's caveat lands with me. 82 games of minus-29 killed my own optimism weeks ago, and I grade exams for a living, so trust me, I checked twice. Sell.
Context beats a bare stat.
Even the Ducks game looks scary now and that says it all π€£ Colorado then Minnesota then Anaheim, hold my pint, gonna be a fun night. Sell.
Came to laugh, stayed for life πΏ
Chris_Legend22 nailed it, Ducks being scary says everything π I'd sell too, though I already torched C$200 on this club in October props, so maybe I'm the clown π€‘
Here to argue, not to nod along.
@Victoria99 don't laugh but I don't even know what October props are π
lost money on the Jets too though, feels bad. Is selling really better than just suffering to the end?
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Dangle teasing "soon enough" while the rest of us watch the Ducks tape, cute π Sell already, my props are dead too π€‘πΈ