Red Wings host the Jets on October 4, two leaky defences
I keep my spreadsheet updated through the whole season, and Detroit against Winnipeg on October 4 looks like a betting trap if you chase the moneyline π Red Wings sit 16th with 92 points but they've been outscored 241-258, and Winnipeg down in 26th have shipped 260 against 231 for. Two sides leaking chances at both ends, so the total line deserves a longer look than picking a winner β especially early season when defensive structure is still shaky. Anyone else leaning over here?
Context beats a bare stat.
Small samples this early make the moneyline messy; with a combined minus-47 goal difference, the over or a total play has more value than picking a winner. π
Do the math before you argue.
Old Original Six vs the '90s Jets, always felt like a real rivalry to me π. History aside, both sides leak goals, total looks juicier than the moneyline here. π₯
Bankroll discipline wins.
Watched us lose 5-4 heartbreakers all season and STILL believe π₯ our lot never make it easy - over total for me, but my heart says the boys pull it off in Detroit πͺ
You don't abandon your own.
Yeah I'd have chased the over on that TorontoLoyal tip and it would've landed - when two teams combine for a minus-47 goal difference, you're not betting outcomes, you're betting chaos. My lean for October 4 is the over first, puck line second, moneyline last.
Winnipeg shipping 260 all season is the tell for me. Detroit at home with 92 points should have some pride to play for in front of their own crowd, but that 241-258 record says they don't defend leads worth a damn, so I'd expect a back-and-forth one. Moneyline here is a coin flip priced like a favourite, been burned on that exact setup too many times, dropped a few hundred C$ on "better team at home" spots like this. I'll put my C$ on the total instead. π₯
Everyone piling on the over like minus-47 guarantees fireworks, show me the numbers on their goalies before we call it chaos. I'll believe it when I see it.
Where's the proof?
Harry has a fair point about the goalies, but here's my angle: look at the schedule context instead. Detroit go into this one with three more games stacked right behind it, MontrΓ©al away on the 10th, then New Jersey and Philadelphia at home. Winnipeg face Anaheim, Minnesota and Chicago in the same window. When a coach is managing ice time across a stretch like that, the bottom six gets more minutes, and bottom-six minutes against two leaky bluelines usually mean goals at both ends.
My table says the same thing the points do: Detroit outscored by 17 over 82 games, Winnipeg by 29. Two teams that finish in the red on goal difference rarely play careful hockey in October when they're both chasing wins early. So I'd take the over as my main play, keep the moneyline away entirely, and size it small, a flat C$20 unit, nothing more. If Hellebuyck-type goaltending shows up and it ends 3-2, so be it; one bad goalie night beats chasing a coin-flip winner. π
Context beats a bare stat.
Harry has a fair point about the goalies, but here's my angle: look at the schedule context instead. Detroit go into this one with three more games stacked right behind it, MontrΓ©al away on the 10th, then New Jersey and β¦
@Sam_YYC1980 schedule angle's interesting but word going round camp is neither team likes the look of their own end right now π take that how you want
Sam's schedule point is the piece I'd weight heaviest here, honestly, neither club has any reason to conserve anything with games stacked right behind this one, which only feeds the chaos argument. That said, one game is one game, and I've tracked enough of these matchups to know a minus-47 combined difference tells you about a season, rarely about a Tuesday night. Keep the total as your lean, keep the moneyline small if at all, and let the goalies settle it live.
Numbers > vibes.
Two leaky defences plus goalies nobody trusts? π± that's over all day for me tbh. I grew up watching HNIC every saturday and games like this always turn into track meets - nobody wanna be the guy backchecking in game one lol π₯
And Sam's point about the schedule is fair, we all know early season hockey is sloppy as hell, both benches gonna be rolling lines and emptying the tank. Harry, buddy, show ME a goalie in this matchup who's gonna calm it down π I'll wait π€¬πͺ
In the stands since I was a kid.
"Word going round camp". Whose camp, Dangle? That's a vibes source, not a source. Chaos angle's fine but show me the numbers first: what did both clubs actually give up in preseason, and who's starting in each net on the 4th? Until then I'm reading these two defences as bad, just differently bad.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Diehard_Faithful wants numbers from a preseason nobody takes seriously π€‘ that's a lottery, not sport. I'd rather trust Dangle's camp whisper than one meaningless exhibit game stat π
Any stat can be bent.
@Sam_YYC1980 schedule angle's interesting but word going round camp is neither team likes the look of their own end right now π take that how you want
@Dangle camp whisper from who exactly, your cousin's barber? π Still, I'll take vibes over Diehard's preseason spreadsheet, those games mean squat. Honestly I put a toonie on over last October openers and got burned twice, so maybe I'm the leaky defence here. Which netminder do you hear is getting the nod on the 4th?
Here to argue, not to nod along.