Predators vs Sharks on October 16: two clubs with 86 points
I'd take San Jose as the worse club and I don't think it's particularly close. Same 86 points after 82, sure, but the routes differ: the Sharks have one extra win and eight fewer loser points, which suggests they lost outright more often. The goal totals settle it for me anyway - Nashville at 247-269 sits at -22, San Jose at 251-292 is -41. A 19-goal gap in differential is the kind of thing you don't talk your way around.
There's a nuance here about sample size, though: one 82-game slate isn't a law of nature, and a single October meeting can go sideways regardless of last season's table. That said, if I'm picking which defence I trust to hold up over a full run, it's Nashville's, easily. Sharks concede nearly a goal more per game on average when you count it strictly. October 16 at Bridgestone, I lean Preds on the puck line. 📊
Numbers > vibes.
I'd argue DiehardFan has it backwards, honestly. Eight fewer loser points with 39 wins means San Jose won more games outright, that reads like a team that plays to the final horn, not one that stumbles into extra time and loses anyway. The 292 goals against is ugly, no argument there, but the goal difference gap (Nashville -22, San Jose -41) partly reflects Nashville winning low-event games while bleeding points in them.
Do the math before you argue.
Whatever the loser-point math says, I keep thinking about how these two have played some genuinely grim head-to-heads over the years. Nobody's forgetting that sweep Nashville ran on San Jose after that big trade, and Sharks fans sure haven't. Rivalry memory aside, my money follows the goals column: giving up 292 smells like a fade every night, while 269 against at least keeps puck lines live. I'd need to see the price before loading up, but leaning Preds at home.
Value over a big price 💸
Checked the goalie cards before touching this one and it changes everything for me - Preds at home, moneyline. Sharks allowed 292, that defence doesn't travel well. 🔥
Up one week, down the next. Classic.
Honestly I'd trust the goal column before I trust either of your loser-point stories. 📊 Run it through: Nashville 247-269 is a minus-22, San Jose 251-292 is minus-41 - same 86 points, nearly double the deficit. That's a real gap, and I lean toward the Sharks being the shakier club on merit, even with the extra win. Danny's point about the goalie cards lines up with that; 292 against doesn't travel, and Bridgestone isn't an easy rink to visit.
That said, I stop short of calling it. One game on October 16 with both sides coming off three dates in six nights (Nashville draws Vegas on the 14th, San Jose hosts Boston the same night) means fatigue and matchups can warp everything. I keep a running table for exactly these spots, and tight pairs like this usually split the season series rather than hand out verdicts. I'll say Preds slightly ahead on merit, watch the tape Thursday night, and only then decide whether my money moves. Anyone tracking the puck line instead of the moneyline here?
Context beats a bare stat.
Took the Preds moneyline there too, landed for me. Shark defence on the road at minus-41? No chance I'm touching that side 🔥
The line moves — catch it.
Took the Preds moneyline there too, landed for me. Shark defence on the road at minus-41? No chance I'm touching that side 🔥
@Toque_Loyal same here, cashed mine too 💪 tho I watched that game and nearly threw the remote at the wall in the second, Shark pressure had me sweating lol. Goalie bailed the Preds out big time and nobody in this thread is giving him credit 🤬 ah well, nowt to do, win is a win
In the stands since I was a kid.
Minus-41 on the road and folks still needed four posts to pick the Preds? 😂 Put your C$ where the goal column is, sure thing, mate. 🤡💸
Okay that minus-41 vs minus-22 bit finally clicked for me, same points but way different goal column 😅. Quick question though, is that gap mostly the defence or could a bad goalie season inflate it? Still learning how to read these numbers properly 🙏
New here, soaking it up.