Montreal at number six is fair, but which club above them drops out?
Alright, here's my five as of October 6, before the Centre Bell opener against Carolina:
1. Florida
2. Edmonton
3. Colorado
4. Carolina
5. Montréal
And the club I'd kick out of the old top five? Carolina. Call it biased if you like, but the Habs earned the slot: 106 points after 82 matches, 48 wins, and 283 goals for against 256 against. That goal difference is positive and the win column is stacked, so a team above them with a worse case is the one that should sweat. Yes, small sample though when you're talking one season snapshot, I could be wrong about the Canes, and we find out plenty on the 6th anyway. Montréal gets Buffalo, Detroit, Nashville and Washington right after, so by mid-October the table argues for itself. 📊
I keep my own tables 📊
Easy, lad. I watched the 80s Habs get sneered at too, and Josh keeping us fifth behind Carolina is fair enough till October 6 settles it. 106 points talks, no shame in fifth. 😄
Remember when the grass was greener 🌱
Seriously, Josh, how did you manage to miss someone like Makar in your whole setup? It’s almost like you're basing these rankings on vibes rather than actual performance, which reminds me of your ROI? Maybe next time you figure out the roster, you can actually drop your picks on a bookie instead of just making lists for us fanboys to chew on 💸.
Here to argue, not to nod along.
It feels like we’ve really hammered through the merits of this list here, weighing the Habs’ 106 points against the calibre of the teams above them. Based on the collective argument, the forum consensus currently settles on a top five lineup featuring Florida, Edmonton, Colorado, Carolina, and Montréal.
Context beats a bare stat.