McDavid deserves the C taken away until he learns to defend like a
Gonna say it: taking the C off McDavid would be the dumbest thing this franchise has done since the decade of management we all try to forget. The guy drags this team to unlikely places every spring and you want to humiliate him over one minus-4 night at Rogers Place? Half the bench went quiet because everyone else was defending like tourists, not because Connor forgot how to captain.
And be honest with yourselves, who exactly takes the C? Draisaitl? Nuge? Meanwhile every Canadian fanbase from Toronto to Vancouver would love to watch us melt down over this. The 1993 drought is already a national punchline, no need to hand them more material. Fix the defensive structure around him instead of stripping letters off the best player alive. Sure thing, mate 🤡
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Gonna say it: taking the C off McDavid would be the dumbest thing this franchise has done since the decade of management we all try to forget. The guy drags this team to unlikely places every spring and you want to humil…
Nobody's saying strip the C over one game, Victoria. My issue is the pattern: how many springs in a row do we watch him coast on the backcheck while the captaincy stays untouchable? Give me one full playoff run where he's engaged without the puck and I'll happily admit I was wrong.Nobody's saying strip the C over one game, Victoria. My issue is the pattern: how many springs in a row do we watch him coast on the backcheck while the captaincy stays untouchable? Give me one full playoff run where he's engaged without the puck and I'll happily admit I was wrong.
Where's the proof?
Harry, were we watching the same spring? Guy put up points all through that run and dragged half the lineup on his back. Yeah the backcheck could be better, show me a captain in this league who defends like a third liner and I'll eat my jersey.
You bench went silent for one period, big deal, ah well, nowt to do but move on. Taking the C off him? That's a panic move that'd blow up the room and hand every rival broadcast a story for a month. Through thick and thin with 97, he wears the C till he decides otherwise 🙌🔥
In the stands since I was a kid.
Victoria's right, one ugly night doesn't erase a captaincy. Harry wants a full run of engaged backchecking, fair ask, but I'd table this until we see the next series sample. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Funny how everyone suddenly forgot the Pronger era, when our captain talked trash and then backed it up in his own end every shift. That minus-4 night stung, yeah, I was in my seat watching the bench go quiet, but taking the C off a guy who's carried this franchise since 2015 would be peak Oilers management logic. Harry, remind me of your ROI on these hot takes? 😂
Show me your ROI first 😏
Josh, I was three rows up for that minus-4 game too, my buddy left after the third goal against and I honestly thought about joining him. I side with Puckhead here, though with one caveat: the backcheck gap is real even if the C stays. Small sample caveats all around, but compare how Harry's ideal captain engages without the puck and Connor's own-zone routes and you see what the fuss is about.
Do the math before you argue.
TorontoLoyal, your buddy bailing after the third goal against is basically the whole argument in one guy walking up the stairs 😂 I'll take the other side of the pub here: how many captains around the league get graded on backchecking while putting up the points he does? Pronger was nasty in his own end, sure, but he also had a full defence corps that wasn't held together by tape. Strip the C and watch the "leadership" mob in the media eat us alive for a decade 🤡
Here to argue, not to nod along.
@FourthLineCanuck2012 every captain gets graded on it when he's paid that much, sorry. Points land you a nice regular season, playoffs expose the minus side fast 😭
Value over a big price 💸
Points buy you tickets, defence wins you playoffs. Crosby and Toews backchecked hard their whole careers, and the Canadian Cup drought didn't happen by accident.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Was at that Rogers Place game too, and honestly both sides have a point here. I'd pump the brakes on stripping the C though, one bad night is a small sample. 📊
Numbers > vibes.