Islanders -1.5 vs the Blackhawks on October 8
Loaded up on the Isles -1.5 already, Chicago leaked 275 goals against last year and that number is way too big to ignore on the road opener. Only worry is the Isles' own defence giving up 241, so I'm keeping the stake at a single unit instead of my usual double. Points prop, give me Barzal over on any sane price 💸
Single unit is the right call there. The 62-goal gap in goal differential (233-241 vs 213-275) supports the Isles -1.5, but opener sample size is one game - Chicago's leaky defence doesn't guarantee New York covers by two. I'd rather wait for the line after morning skate and watch the goalie assignment before committing my C$ stake. 📊
Numbers > vibes.
Diehard, "sample size of one game", yeah, that's exactly why the price on -1.5 looks fat, the books price openers like coin flips 😏 275 against doesn't vanish over a summer, that roster got worse if anything. I took it heavier than a single unit and threw a small points prop on the Isles top line too. You passed on it entirely? Cashing nothing on opener night is laughable really 🤡
It's a lottery, not sport.
Kev's got half a point - 275 against doesn't evaporate over one summer, but "got worse if anything" is doing a lot of work there without any receipts. Show me the numbers on that roster before I pay fat juice on a puck line. My issue is the Isles side: 241 against, 19th in the table, and a habit of winning tight rather than covering. A 62-goal differential gap sounds big until you remember it averages out to under a goal a game, which is exactly the margin -1.5 needs twice over.
I'll take the Isles to win, straight up, no hesitation. The -1.5? On condition that I see Chicago's actual defence in game one. And even then it's a single-unit play for me, same as RefBlindSurvivor. Points prop, I'd look at the Chicago side cheap, honestly; when a team ships 275, somebody on the other bench usually eats. I'll believe the Isles are a covering team when I see it.
Where's the proof?
Harry's right to ask for receipts, because Kev has none. What we actually know from last season's table: Chicago went 29-14-39 and bled 275, while the Isles went 43-5-34 with a 233-241 split. So yes, the goal diff gap is real 📊, but two mediocre-at-best offences there, and covering by two on opening night is a coin flip with extra juice. I keep my single unit too, and if I touch a points prop it's on the Isles side, small.
Context beats a bare stat.
Sam's got the receipts, agreed. My accountant rule though: openers get one unit max, and I'd need better than fat juice to lay -1.5 blind in October.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Ever notice how the opener feels like the one night everyone forgets their own spreadsheet? I keep mine every round, and the column that jumps out at me here isn't the 275, it's the 5. Chicago dropping only five in regulation while sitting 31st means they stole points all year in tight losses, which usually smells of a team that got saves on some nights. The Isles' 241 against is the number that actually scares me more than anything Chicago did, because you're laying -1.5 with a club that finished 19th and only four points clear of the bottom feeders on goal differential logic alone.
My read: one unit max like Diehard says, and honestly I'd rather look at a points prop than lay the 1.5 blind. That said, there's a nuance here. The books do price openers conservatively, so if the juice on the puck line is fat AND the Isles' schedule after this one (Tampa, Vancouver, Ottawa) gets ugly fast, this might be the softest spot they get all month.
Context beats a bare stat.
RideOrDie's point about the 5 OT losses is the only thing in this thread worth a second read - that's a coin-flip team hiding under a shiny record, and one-goal games don't cover -1.5. I'll take Chicago +1.5 before I pay juice on the Isles laying it, opener or not. My rule after too many lost Octobers: one unit on the puck line, nothing more, until the rosters actually prove something. Show me the numbers by Halloween and maybe I change my tune.
Hype isn't an argument.
The 5 OT losses cuts both ways, though. Yes, it says the Isles lived in one-goal games, but it also says their worst-case night was a single goal, a team that went 43-5-34 simply doesn't get blown out often, and blowing Chicago out is exactly what a -1.5 cover needs. Sample size caveat applies to all of us, it's one October game, but I'd rather lay the goal against a 275-against side than back the +1.5 hoping for another coin-flip.
On the opener prop angle: keep in mind the Islanders come home to Tampa on October 10 right after this, so rotation and early-season line juggling make me wary of overpaying for anyone's points number. I'd look at price over name here. If the juice on a top Islanders forward is fat because everyone expects a bounce-back night versus the worst defence in the table, that's where the value leaks out. Dig a bit deeper into what bookmaker is charging before you decide the number, not just the side. 📊
Do the math before you argue.
Torn on this one, not gonna lie. RideOrDie's 5 OT point is the reason I haven't touched it yet, those tight Isles games killed my -1.5 tickets all last season, landed by one more times than I can count and I ate the juice. But 275 against is the kind of number you don't just walk past, Chicago looked like a charity case at their own end all year. My rule before I put C$ on any NHL opener: wait for the confirmed starters, especially the goalie. If Sorokin gets the nod I'll probably take a half-unit on the puck line and keep the rest for the points prop instead. Safer than laying the full -1.5 blind on night one. Still watching the line, if it drifts my way I'm in. 😸
Bankroll discipline wins.
Ever notice how the opener feels like the one night everyone forgets their own spreadsheet? I keep mine every round, and the column that jumps out at me here isn't the 275, it's the 5. Chicago dropping only five in regul…
That '5' number sounds big, but maybe I'm missing how much that really matters for the money side. 🙏
Learn something new every day.
Torn on this one, not gonna lie. RideOrDie's 5 OT point is the reason I haven't touched it yet, those tight Isles games killed my -1.5 tickets all last season, landed by one more times than I can count and I ate the juic…
@ReginaLoyal basically you need a two-goal win or the ticket dies, even a close Isles win loses. I'm new too and that one tripped me up at first 🙈 So you'd risk it here?
New here, soaking it up.
ReginaLoyal, it matters a lot for the puck line, that's the whole bet. Isles winning by one does nothing for you at -1.5. I learned that the hard way last season, dropped a few C$50 tickets on teams that "never get blown out" and still landed by one. I need to see who's in goal before I touch this one either way.
The line moves — catch it.
Toque nailed it, winning by one is the classic wallet-killer. I laid -1.5 on "safe" teams all last season and donated enough on Mise-o-jeu to roof a shed 😂
Here to argue, not to nod along.