Is the 'Penguins DNA' just a myth?
DNA talk is cope, honestly. Sidney and Geno carried this franchise for two decades, that was talent, not some fairy dust in the walls. Now everyone wants to pay C$8M a season for "leadership" instead of drafting kids who can actually skate. Take the picks, eat the rebuild, and let the fanboys keep chasing 2009 vibes 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.
DNA talk is cope, honestly. Sidney and Geno carried this franchise for two decades, that was talent, not some fairy dust in the walls. Now everyone wants to pay C$8M a season for "leadership" instead of drafting kids who…
You're missing the point on how consistency translates into competitive advantage. Show me the stats on win rates correlating to those different investment strategies.
Hype isn't an argument.
PuckheadDad840, I keep a table on this every round and the honest answer is we don't have the sample size to prove either strategy wins games, so demanding "the stats" is a bit rich. My lean, for what it's worth, is with Victoria on the money side: paying C$8M a season for leadership while the prospect pipeline dries up is how franchises spend a decade in the mushy middle. Culture matters, sure, but Sid after 2016 came from a deep young core too. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
I grew up on those 2009 runs, that room had somethin special tbh. But C$8M for a guy cheering from the press box? Nah. Draft kids, keep Sid's lessons. Ah well, nowt to do 🤬
In the stands since I was a kid.
Puckhead_Eh mate, that C$8M press box line is doing a lot of work for a guy who grew up on the 2009 runs 😱
Remind me what Sid's lessons win us when the kids can't skate past a forecheck? Nobody's saying draft badly. But you don't rebuild a room by tossing every vet overboard either... look at the Habs, they've been "developing kids" since forever and where's it got them lately? Half a decade of picking top ten and still no culture to show for it 🤬
Heart says you keep guys who've actually lifted the Cup in that room, even pricey. Skinny kids with cheap entry deals don't teach anyone how to win down 2-3 🔥
In the stands since I was a kid.
RideOrDie, fair point on sample size, but I'll believe the DNA premium when someone shows me it outperforms the cap hit. Paying for vibes at C$8M? Not convinced.
Where's the proof?
Harry, I'm with you, the DNA premium has to beat the cap hit to matter. Caveat though, small sample everywhere. I sat behind the bench glass in 2017 and you could feel what the old guard did 📊
Do the math before you argue.
I'd rather watch a 19 year old kid botch a breakout for a season than pay one more vet C$8M to tell stories about 2009 in the room. DNA or no DNA, the puck drops the same for guys who can't skate anymore. Victoria's right and it hurts to type that 😂
Funnily enough, both camps in this thread are arguing past each other on the same point. The C$8M leadership spend only pays if the kids around it develop faster because of it, and nobody's shown me a sample big enough to prove that either way. My table says track it over three seasons before we crown or kill the DNA theory. Until then I'm keeping the argument open, and my beer cold at the pub pregame.
Numbers > vibes.
Funnily enough, both camps in this thread are arguing past each other on the same point. The C$8M leadership spend only pays if the kids around it develop faster because of it, and nobody's shown me a sample big enough t…
@DiehardFan this is fair tbh, no one's got a big enough sample on either side. But I played minor hockey with a couple aging vets in the room and you just know the young guys picked up habits they'd never learn from a drill sheet 🤷♂️ maybe it's worth one C$8M gamble if the kid pool is thin, who develops faster without anyone showing them how to be a pro?
One love, one side ❤️
I don't totally get the money stuff with the C$8M contracts. Do the veterans ever help the kids at all even if the scouting isn't perfect?
Dumb questions are my specialty.