If the Flames sit 29th with 77 points
Fire sale? Look at the goal column, 212 for and 259 against, that answers itself for me. You don't climb out of that with a couple of rental vets at the deadline, those guys cost picks and walk in July anyway.
Word going round the Saddledome concourse is the cap space gets pointed one direction only, and people who know, know which one 😏. I'm not naming a source, the source won't hold if I do. But sitting 29th with 77 points, if the plan is still "add depth for a push" before that October 9 opener against Colorado, I'd love to hear who's pushing. Nobody in this building believes it. Half-hint from me, full clear-out from them, that's my read 🤫
The jump from 29th place to contention isn't solely dependent on goal differential metrics. You are suggesting a full rebuild is the only option because of the scoring, but that overlooks the value of flexible cap space for short-term fixes. Before declaring a fire sale necessary, I want to see the specific projections on the veterans' contracts compared to potential deadline targets. I'm not convinced the current roster lack of points could be solved by wholesale dismantling.
Where's the proof?
Nah Harry, minus 47 in goal differential doesn't get fixed by rental band-aids 😱 kids and picks, burn it down, through thick and thin 🔥
In the stands since I was a kid.
Nah Harry, minus 47 in goal differential doesn't get fixed by rental band-aids 😱 kids and picks, burn it down, through thick and thin 🔥
Puckhead, I'm mostly with you, but one caveat: a minus 47 goal differential on a 82-game sample tells you the roster as constructed can't climb, it doesn't tell you the rebuild has to be total. I keep my own tables every round and the pattern is usually the same, teams that move expiring vets for picks first, then spend the cap space in July rather than at the deadline. If they open the season October 9 against Colorado still ice-cold at the Saddledome, sure, burn it down. Before that date arrives I'd at least see what the flexible space buys in the summer.
Do the math before you argue.
TorontoLoyal has it right. 29th with 77 points and Colorado first at the Dome on October 9, sell the expirings, keep the kids. Show me a rental that covers minus 47.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Diehard_Faithful, I've been keeping a spreadsheet on this roster for three seasons now and the column that always buries them is the one nobody wants to look at. 259 against over 82 games is a structural problem, so yes, sell the expirings at the deadline and bank the picks. My caveat with TorontoLoyal's point is that "partial rebuild" and "total rebuild" get blurred depending how you count it. A housecleaning of veteran expirings plus one or two bad contracts moved out is already a halfway rebuild, and nobody in the building will call it that. Sample size caveat though, one 82-game season is a real sample but an unusual injury year can distort it. I watched the last home date at the Saddledome from section 104 and the crowd knew by the second period what this team was. Kids and picks, sell early rather than late, because waiting for the March crunch never returns fair value. Then Colorado at the Dome on October 9 tells us everything about where the young core actually stands.
Numbers > vibes.
Dead thread? Nobody's asked the obvious: what does "fire sale" actually mean here? Everyone keeps saying sell expirings, but nobody's priced the difference between that and a full teardown. I'll believe the rebuild talk when someone shows which contracts actually move. Losing at home to Colorado on October 9 by a couple goals won't tell us anything either way, that game's a coin flip on paper.
Hype isn't an argument.
Dead thread? Nobody's asked the obvious: what does "fire sale" actually mean here? Everyone keeps saying sell expirings, but nobody's priced the difference between that and a full teardown. I'll believe the rebuild talk …
@PuckheadDad840 finally someone asking the real question 😂 teardown means moves nobody wants to price because the answer is ugly. Half these expiring deals move for a 2nd and a bag of pucks, so "fire sale" talk is mostly cope. And in reality? 259 against fixes itself with neither route. You priced any of it yourself or just waiting for Winnipeg_True's mystery DMs 🤡
It's a lottery, not sport.
I've been tracking the defensive zone metrics, and you're right, a 259 against figure is brutal, regardless of the offense scoring 212. But before we declare a total fire sale, we have to really dig a bit deeper into the contracts of the veterans. Not every expiring deal moves equally, and the quality of the picks we receive in exchange is what truly determines if this is damage control or the beginning of a full rebuild.
Context beats a bare stat.
RideOrDie4Life, three seasons of spreadsheets and the buried column is still 259 goals against, that's the whole answer mate 😏. Remind me, which expiring deal actually moves before October 9 when Colorado walks into the Saddledome? Wait for the fanboys to pile in with "keep the kids" like a minus 47 fixes itself 🤡💸
Here to argue, not to nod along.
RideOrDie4Life, three seasons of spreadsheets and the buried column is still 259 goals against, that's the whole answer mate 😏. Remind me, which expiring deal actually moves before October 9 when Colorado walks into the …
@Victoria99 easy there mate, I've watched long enough to know October hockey decides nothing about trades. front office will wait till prices sharpen at the deadline, that's how these things always go 😉
Watch as long as I have and you'll get it.
Heard something off a contact, take it for what it's worth 🤫 word going round the Saddledome side is the expirings get moved closer to the deadline, not before October 9 when Colorado rolls in. 259 against tells you the direction anyway. Details in the DMs if anyone's keen 😏
wait, insider info lives in DMs now? 🤣 I'm a graphic designer, my "contact" is the bloke who pours me pints and he says the same thing every October: wait and see 😂
Only serious one here, barely.