Hot take from the Bell Centre concourse
Hot take from me: this squad misses Pricey more than anyone in management will say out loud. Montembeault puts up decent numbers at the Bell Centre and the fanboys will wave his save percentage around all season, sure thing mate, but ask yourself who you want facing a shootout with a playoff spot on the line 😏 Price in his prime stole twenty points a year on his own. Sad but true.
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Hot take from me: this squad misses Pricey more than anyone in management will say out loud. Montembeault puts up decent numbers at the Bell Centre and the fanboys will wave his save percentage around all season, sure th…
Shootout argument is a bit rich when Price couldn't stop a beach ball in the skills competition his last couple of years. Montembeault's home save percentage beats Price's final full season, that's just arithmetic, not fanboy talk. I loved Carey like everyone here, but the guy in the crease now is who this roster actually has. Nostalgia doesn't stop pucks.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Faithful's got the arithmetic right, Montembeault's home save percentage does beat Price's final full season at the Bell Centre. There's a nuance here though: one season of home splits is a thin sample, and Price's value was never really the shootout, it was stealing games a rebuild-tier roster had no business keeping close. I'll take Monty gladly, but Halifax isn't wrong that nobody game-plans around facing him. 📊
Numbers > vibes.
Remember Price stealing 40+ wins behind some brutal rosters back then. Monty's numbers are nice, but I lost count of the games Carey just refused to lose. Different weight. 💙
Bankroll discipline wins.
OttawaLocal nailed it with the "refused to lose" line. Montembeault's home save percentage is real, but one season of splits is a thin sample, so I keep my own table on this and it always trends the same way: Price dragged rebuild rosters over the line night after night. I still remember standing in the 300s watching him steal a game the team had no business being in. Different weight entirely.
Do the math before you argue.
TorontoLoyal keeping a table on it 😂 cute. Monty's numbers are fine, nobody's punching their TV when he's hot, that's the whole test. Price made you believe every night. Sad but true.
Show me your ROI first 😏
Nah, that "believing every night" thing is pure nostalgia talking 😂 Care to tell me who carried the dang puck up ice for Carey back then? Nobody. Whole offence was him standing on his head and 25 minutes of shot blocks.
Monty gets an actual blue line in front of him now and people still whine. Sure, Price's numbers get a pass because he won the Hart behind trash rosters, fair enough, that was unreal. But save percentage is save percentage, don't care how you slice it. One bad night from Monty and suddenly everyone's printing #31 jerseys again 🙄 Put some respect on the guy, we're trying to make the playoffs here 🔥💙
Nostalgia? Mate I watched Price rob Toronto in the 2021 bubble live, gave up my Timmies run for that 😤 Monty's good, Carey was otherworldly. 🙌
You don't abandon your own.
The bubble run is the right memory, Vancouver99, because that was Price carrying a roster that finished bottom-half in scoring into a final. I'll grant Montembeault his home splits, on condition that someone shows me him stealing a playoff series the same way. Until then my gut says the gap is real.
Where's the proof?
Harry nailed it. Price stole Toronto in 2021, first round, and I still have the game notes from that night in my grading binder. Monty needs one stolen series before I put him in that conversation. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Put Monty in a bubble Toronto series with that 2021 defence and he gets cooked in five, I'd bet a C$20 prop on it. Steal a series first, then talk. 😏
Any stat can be bent.
Cooked in five? Steve I'll take that C$20 prop and shake on it 😤 you watched Monty stand on his head at the Bell all winter same as me. Sure he hasn't stolen a series yet, but Pricey had years of playoff chances before the bubble run too, so give the bloke a chance ffs 🔥
One love, one side ❤️
Calgary makes a fair point though, Price had a pile of first-round exits before 2021 ever happened. Context matters with the save percentages too, home splits hide who faced what in front of them. I'll referee Steve's C$…
@Calgary that prop's bad value for you, honestly. Steve priced it as a joke but the 2021 defence in front of whoever was playing goal that year was paper thin, no way Monty drags that roster anywhere near five games with the bullets coming in. I'd side with Steve on this one and I don't say that lightly.
Home splits are the trap here, Sam nailed it. I loaded up on a Monty moneyline at the Bell once thinking the home form would travel, it didn't, and I ate it. Road numbers tell you who the goalie actually is. Price had earned his playoff reps by then, Monty hasn't got a single series yet. Give me that C$20 side of the shake. 💸
Up one week, down the next. Classic.
Calgary makes a fair point though, Price had a pile of first-round exits before 2021 ever happened. Context matters with the save percentages too, home splits hide who faced what in front of them. I'll referee Steve's C$20 prop for free, but I want both goalies judged on stolen starts, not just a number on the concourse board. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Calgary makes a fair point though, Price had a pile of first-round exits before 2021 ever happened. Context matters with the save percentages too, home splits hide who faced what in front of them. I'll referee Steve's C$…
@Sam_YYC1980 free refereeing? Bold offer from a guy whose last "analysis" aged like milk in July 😂 context cuts both ways pal, remind me of your ROI?
Here to argue, not to nod along.