Honest take, family: this rebuild should have started two years
Two more years of watching Toews and Kane chase a ghost while the cup window was already shut, that's loyalty? Nah. Every month they hung onto that core in 2023 was a month we weren't stacking picks. I said it then and I'll say it now, an earlier teardown gets us more draft capital and we're not sitting here debating what could've been.
And before the fanboys pile in with the "you don't trade legends" speeches, nobody's saying we had to ship them out on a garbage barge. But the front office treated a closed window like it was still open, and that's on them. What's the actual return on two extra seasons of sentimental hockey? Show me that and maybe I'll soften up. 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.
And what exactly were we getting for them, Victoria? Name the haul. A 35-year-old rental with a no-move clause and a say in where he lands fetches a conditional second and a prospect nobody remembers. That's the market, that was the market in 2023 too. Teams don't pay firsts for half a season of a guy who walks in July. So the great "stack
Sample first, conclusions after.
Nah Diehard, the market argument falls apart when you remember Kane had a full no-move and STILL got shipped to the Rangers for a package, Toews just chose to stay. That's on nobody but the org for never even shopping him properly. I sat through every Saturday on Hockey Night in Canada in 2023-24 watching a hollowed-out roster bleed out, and every loss was a pick we didn't have... if the rebuild starts in 2022, Bedard isn't the story, the war chest around him is. Loyalty's beautiful at the pub, it costs you drafts at the table 🤬🔥
You don't abandon your own.
Diehard_Faithful has the right read on the market, honestly. A pending UFA with a full no-move and declining numbers was never fetching a first in 2023, look at what Kane actually landed and it was a conditional package, nothing more. There's a nuance here though: Vancouver99's point about Toews never even being shopped properly stands, and that's where the org burned option value we can't get back. Small sample caveat aside, that alone argues the rebuild should've started earlier 📊
Numbers > vibes.
I was in the United Center in '15 when the core won that third cup, so believe me, nobody here wanted to say goodbye to Toews and Kane. But the window didn't close politely, it slammed shut and everybody saw it except the org. Holding two declining forwards with full no-moves through 2023 while the 2023 draft class sat there waiting, that wasn't loyalty, that was avoiding an awkward phone call.
Diehard's right that the market for those rentals was thin, Kane's package proves it. Vancouver's right that nobody even shopped Toews honestly. Two things true at once. The real waste is that a proper rebuild starting in 2022 means one extra draft of high picks and maybe we're not scraping for a first-rounder in every conversation now. I'll believe the current plan works when I see the numbers at next year's deadline.
Hype isn't an argument.
Went through this exact argument with my buddy over pints at the pub before a Rocket game, and I'll say what I told him: loyalty to Toews was fine, pretending the window was open was the real sin. Diehard's right that the haul was gonna be a conditional second at best, so shop him or don't, the org saved face either way. Meanwhile two years of picks just evaporated. And in reality, what did staying buy us, one more lost spring? 😏
Any stat can be bent.
SniperGuy, even scraps add up though 🤔 look at Montreal turning spare parts into picks with the Habs teardown. A later start still beat no start, no? 🙏
Harry, this is the piece most people skip, seller prices decay month by month. I keep my own little spreadsheet every deadline and the pattern holds: a renting 35-point second liner in November pulls a second plus a pros…
@EllieLoves scraps add up but scraps two years later buy way less, Harry's right tbh 🤬 Shoulda sold Kane when the price was hot. Ah well, nowt to do 💪
In the stands since I was a kid.
Ellie's got a point, but the timing piece matters more than she thinks. A trade-deadline seller's price drops every month you wait, so Kane's value in '23 was never going to be what it was a year earlier, whatever the actual return ended up being. I'll believe the org maximized anything when someone shows me the numbers, and so far nobody has.
Where's the proof?
Harry, this is the piece most people skip, seller prices decay month by month. I keep my own little spreadsheet every deadline and the pattern holds: a renting 35-point second liner in November pulls a second plus a prospect, the same guy in March pulls a third and a bag of pucks. That's just how buyers negotiate, they know you're cornered.
Where I'd push back slightly is on the word "never". Kane's value was already sliding through 2022, sure, but there was a stretch after the trade call rules loosened where the market briefly overpaid for shooters. That was the actual window to sell, and it closed fast. My old man and I missed it too, we were arguing about this over Timmies before a game in November and I told him holding was fine. Still bugs me I got that one wrong. Ellie's half right though, even late scraps compound, look at how Montreal kept squeezing picks out of nothing. Just dig a bit deeper on timing and the whole picture sharpens. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Seriously @RideOrDie4Life your spreadsheet sounds like it's ready for a Wall Street presentation, I hope it doesn't need a mandatory Q1 review before you send it. Still, the decay thing is kinda real, like watching a hot playoff bubble pop. It’s just sad how skill valuation turns into accounting, eh? 😂🍿
Only serious one here, barely.
RideOrDie's decay curve is the honest crux here, and honestly nobody's shown the return side of it: what did Kane and Toews actually fetch at deadline versus what a 2022 move plausibly would've? Without that comparison the loyalty-versus-picks question stays open. Sample size of one deadline, so I'm not calling a verdict either way.
Do the math before you argue.