Honest question, family: is Connor Bedard already our best player
Under two minutes of third-period ice for Bedard against Utah and some of you still type "too early" with a straight face π€‘ mate, the kid IS the best player on this roster, and it stopped being a debate around Christmas. Richardson hiding him in crunch time isn't player protection, that's a coach coaching scared with a C$90M franchise piece stapled to the fourth line.
And to the folks who'll wait for the fanboys to pile in before saying he's "not there yet" - remind me who else on this team you'd want taking a faceoff down a goal with three minutes left? Exactly. Sure thing, mate, keep DEVELOPING him, see where the standings get us π
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Under two minutes of third-period ice for Bedard against Utah and some of you still type "too early" with a straight face π€‘ mate, the kid IS the best player on this roster, and it stopped being a debate around Christmas.β¦
Best player on the roster by Christmas? He's been good, I'll give you that. But one short third against Utah proves nothing either way - show me the numbers over a full season before I crown him.
Where's the proof?
Under two minutes against Utah?? π€¬ Richardson's burying the kid tbh. Best player already, no debate for me π₯ backing Bedard all day πͺ
One love, one side β€οΈ
Harry, I'm mostly with you, and I keep a sheet on this stuff every round, so hear me out. The under-two-minute third against Utah looks ugly in isolation, but there's a nuance here: Richardson has been leaning on Bedard hard earlier in games, and when a club is down a bundle in the third, coaches tend to go with veterans to "manage" the scoreboard. That's protection with a downside, if you ask me, the kid learns closing minutes by playing them.
Now, best player on the roster already? Victoria, dig a bit deeper before we hand him the crown at Christmas. He's clearly our most talented forward and the pace of his development has been ahead of schedule, but a full-season sample needs to show it against matchup lines, not just sheltered shifts. Talent-wise yes, crown-wise let's see the full 82. π
Context beats a bare stat.
Reminds me of old-timers talking about a young Kane here lol, we've barely watched Bedard a full season and people want him crowned already π still learning this stuff though, thanks RideOrDie4Life for the nuance!
New here, soaking it up.
RideOrDie4Life keeping a "sheet" lol π reminding me of your ROI on those predictions, mate? Kid drags this lineup every shift and you're doing analytics defence for Richardson π€‘
Show me your ROI first π
Define "best player" first, because half this thread is arguing past each other. Best by raw talent? Probably yes already. Best by results? Show me the numbers over a full season, not one bad third period against Utah.
That said, under two minutes in the third is hard to defend. If the coach is protecting a rookie from defensive-zone drag, fine, say that. But nobody protects a guy they consider their best player. RideOrDie's sheet-collecting is more rigorous than most takes here, I'll give him that, but JoshTims has a point buried under the clown emojis: you don't ration minutes for the franchise. I'll believe the "best player" talk when Richardson actually treats him like one at 15:00 of the third.
Hype isn't an argument.
PuckheadDad840 said it fairest here, and I'll add my usual caveat: one sheltered third period is a single data point, and I've got a whole spreadsheet proving small samples will lie to you π. That said, I was at the Utah game. Flew in for it, even. And watching Bedard stapled to the bench while the game drifted felt wrong regardless of context. Give it a full season before crowning anyone, but by talent? Yeah, the kid's already the guy.
Do the math before you argue.
TorontoLoyal flew in for THAT and still watched Richardson park our best player for the whole third π you paid a plane ticket to see two minutes of Bedard, that's the most Blackhawks thing I've ever heard.
Honestly the sheltering excuse only holds if the kid was drowning out there, and he wasn't. He's the only one on this roster who creates something every shift. If Richardson wants to "protect" him, protect him by giving him the zone starts that matter, not by benching him in a game we actually could've won. PuckheadDad wants a full season of numbers, fine, but I'd take the over on Bedard outproducing everyone on this roster by March, and yes I've already got a bit down at the book on it. What's everyone else waiting for, eh?
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Two minutes in the third?? I watched that game at the pub and nearly threw my drink π€¬ kid was our best forward that night, burying him does nothing for anyone... Richardson's gotta trust him more, full stop πͺ
You don't abandon your own.
Was he really our best forward though?? π
I thought he lost a bunch of puck battles early, maybe Richardson sat him for that. Don't laugh, guys
Was he really our best forward though?? π
I thought he lost a bunch of puck battles early, maybe Richardson sat him for that. Don't laugh, guys
@TimsRunDad nah not laughing, fair question. Every kid loses battles, coaches know that. Two minutes in the third tho? That's on Richardson, not the kid π€¬
One love, one side β€οΈ
TimsRunDad, fair question actually. From what I saw, a few lost battles early doesn't justify under two minutes in the whole third. Richardson's sheltered tough matchups all season, but this looked more like default habit than a response to how Bedard was playing. Protecting him maybe, burying him no, hard to develop your franchise guy when he's stapled to the bench in the third.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Been keeping my own tracking sheet on his shifts all season, and there's a nuance here, under two minutes in one third period reads differently than a pattern, and one game is a small sample. But TimsRunDad has a point that early lost battles can earn you a benching, while Faithful's right that Richardson's sheltering habit predates that Utah game. I'd say the "is he our best player" question and the "did Richardson handle the third right" question are separate arguments, and neither is settled yet. π
Numbers > vibes.
Word going round from folks close to the room is Richardson's ride-or-die habits die hard with young centre icetime π one short third means nothing yet. Ask me again after ten more games whether Bedard's already the guy, those who know, know. π€«