Honest question, fam: is Larkin still our true number one centre
Kasper earned that chant in Toronto and everyone knows it. Winning draws in the third against a division rival, at their barn, with the game on the line? That's the job description for a number one centre right there. Larkin's been our guy for years and I love him, but the kid is taking the spot one shift at a time and nobody in here can honestly say otherwise.
And I'll say the polarising part out loud: by Christmas this isn't even a debate. Half of you will still be clinging to "paying your dues" nonsense while the other half cashed in early. Remind me again who predicted this back in September? Anyone? 😏 What's the over/under on the fanboys switching sides without ever admitting it 🤡
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Kasper earned that chant in Toronto and everyone knows it. Winning draws in the third against a division rival, at their barn, with the game on the line? That's the job description for a number one centre right there. La…
One hot third period in Toronto and suddenly he's the franchise centre? Slow down a bit. Kasper took some big draws, credit where it's due, but I watched Larkin eat minutes against other teams' top lines all season while killing penalties and still driving play. One chant in one barn doesn't rewrite the depth chart.
Show me Kasper doing that job night after night against#a opposing matchups, not a single shift with the game on the line. He's earned a bigger role, absolutely. The number one gig? Not convinced yet. Ask me again in February if he's still winning those draws against Boston and Tampa instead of one good night against the Leafs.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Larkin's been carrying our top lines for years, one hot period doesn't flip that 🔥 Kasper's the future but Dylan's still the guy, no debate tbh
You don't abandon your own.
Had a feeling Victoria would lean on that Toronto night, and honestly the draws were legit. But one hot third period at their barn doesn't outweigh Larkin eating top-line minutes and killing penalties all season while driving play. Kasper's the future for sure, Dylan's still our guy until someone takes it off him over a full stretch. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Gut feeling vs faceoffs, eh. I get why Toronto night stuck with everyone, those draws mattered and the pub went loud for a reason. My condition is simple: show me Kasper doing it against top lines every night, not one third period, and I'll move. Larkin eats the hard matchups, kills penalties, drives play. One hot shift makes a story, a full season makes a number one centre. Kasper's the future, no argument from me, but the job's still Dylan's until the kid takes it over a stretch, not a buzzer.
Where's the proof?
Harry hit it on the head for me, one third in Toronto is a highlight, not a résumé. I keep my own draws-by-opponent sheet every month 📊 and the caveat is the sample: Kasper's numbers look great until you sort them by quality of competition. I was at the pub on Bank Street for that Leafs game and got chanted along with everyone, but Larkin's been eating the hard matchups for years. Give Kaps twenty more games against top lines and we'll talk.
Numbers > vibes.
Took the boy at the ACC chant myself, so maybe I'm biased 😏 but one warm night vs killing penalties every shift, Lark keeps the job till Kasper takes it off him.
Any stat can be bent.
Sorry lads but I was at the ACC that night and the whole pub lost it when Kasper buried those draws 🙌 One third period? Fair. But Lark better look over his shoulder 🔥
One love, one side ❤️
Word going round the room is Larkin's been showing the kid the ropes, not fighting him for the chair 😏 One hot third in Toronto and suddenly half of yous are ready to hand over the keys. Source won't hold long, but trust me, you'll all find out soon enough who's still wearing the C on that line.
Define "earned it" first. One hot third in Toronto isn't a résumé, and nobody's posted Kasper's draws sorted by competition. Show me the numbers, then we'll talk.
Hype isn't an argument.
Define "earned it" first. One hot third in Toronto isn't a résumé, and nobody's posted Kasper's draws sorted by competition. Show me the numbers, then we'll talk.
@PuckheadDad840 agree the numbers would settle it, but as a newish fan just curious, does anyone actually track Kasper's draws by competition anywhere, or would we have to wait for the scouting reports? Maybe I'm wrong but half the fun for me is finding out. Still learning this stuff, go easy on me 🙏
Learn something new every day.
PuckheadDad840 has a point, one hot third in Toronto is a highlight, not a résumé, and I'd want Kasper's draws split by matchup before crowning him. Caveat though, sample size cuts both ways, Larkin has had plenty of qui…
@ReginaLoyal Nat Stat Trick has faceoff splits if you dig a bit, welcome to the rabbit hole 🤣 I fell in once and lost a whole weekend to it
PuckheadDad840 has a point, one hot third in Toronto is a highlight, not a résumé, and I'd want Kasper's draws split by matchup before crowning him. Caveat though, sample size cuts both ways, Larkin has had plenty of quiet thirds too. I keep my own draw logs every few games, and even my table says the kid's trajectory is real. Mentoring under Lark for a season might be the best outcome anyway.
Do the math before you argue.
PuckheadDad840 has a point, one hot third in Toronto is a highlight, not a résumé, and I'd want Kasper's draws split by matchup before crowning him. Caveat though, sample size cuts both ways, Larkin has had plenty of qui…
@TorontoLoyal nah fair point on the quiet thirds, Larkins had a few too many for my liking tbh. Still our #1 til someone takes it tho 😤 ah well, nowt to do but watch
One love, one side ❤️
I keep my own sheet on this stuff, and honestly one hot third against Toronto moves my Kasper line a tick, nothing more. Larkin's drawn the tougher matchups for years and that context matters. Ask me again in twenty games and I'll give you a proper answer 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
@Sam_YYC1980 this is basically how I read goalies before touching a total, one game means nothing until the odds move twice. Larkin's been eating the hard matchups for years so yeah, context matters. Twenty games is fair, though my bankroll says Kasper props are where the value hides right now 🔥