Honest question, fam: is Charlie McAvoy still our true number one
Was at the Garden last week for the pre-game pints and this exact argument nearly ended a friendship, so might as well have it here. Lindholm's been swallowing 24+ a night against other teams' best lines while Charlie watches in a suit, and honestly? Best defenceman plays, title or no title. Wait for the McAvoy fanboys to pile in 😏
Any stat can be bent.
Big minutes against tired lines while our best partner is hurt? Show me the numbers against full-strength rosters and I'll believe it. Charlie's still my guy.
Where's the proof?
Hoser, tired lines? He's shutting down top units night after night, that's not charity minutes 😤 Charlie's still my boy and I'll defend him through thick and thin, but Hampus earned the throne till he's back. Give him the PP1 too, ah well, nowt to do 🔥
In the stands since I was a kid.
If he’s putting up 24 plus minutes against their elite units, then Hampus definitely earned his stripes in that window while Charlie was gone.
Context beats a bare stat.
Seen this debate a few times over the decades, fellas. Best defenceman is whoever's on the ice when it matters, and right now that's Hampus. 😉
Watch as long as I have and you'll get it.
My spreadsheet has a column called "context" and right now it's full of asterisks 📊. Twenty-four minutes against top lines while Charlie's in the room tells me Hampus can carry the load, but who wears the crown gets settled against full rosters with both of them dressed. PP1 split is the real fight, and I'm keeping the tab open at the pub on that one.
Context beats a bare stat.