Forget fancy wingers - who's our new shutdown defenceman to protect
Word from a buddy who drinks with a guy that follows the beat reporters is we're sniffing around a stay-at-home lefty in the C$5-6M range, name I heard made me raise an eyebrow, so take it with a grain of salt. But apparently Sakic's priority all along was a proper shutdown d-man before anything flashy up front, which honestly tracks.
Meanwhile half this thread will tell you we should blow the whole pile on a fancy winger and pray nobody decapitates Mackinnon on a rush the other way. Genius stuff. 😏 And for the guys who keep posting their dream lineups with zero idea of the cap math, remind me of your ROI on those hot takes? 🤡💸
Here to argue, not to nod along.
A buddy of a buddy of a beat guy. Solid sourcing. Show me the numbers, or a name, or anything beyond pub talk. Not convinced.
Sample first, conclusions after.
I'd pump the brakes on the C$5-6M figure until we see a name attached. A legit shutdown lefty in that range exists, sure, but the ones who actually kill penalties and start shifts in their own end tend to command closer to C$7M-plus once you factor in term. A guy on the wrong side of 30 eating that kind of AAV for four or five years is exactly the contract that looks ugly in year three.
The logic of the fit is fine, we've been soft on the wall against forechecking teams all season, and the tape backs up what SniperGuy is feeling. Small sample caveat though: a handful of bad playoff games will make the D look worse than the underlying numbers suggest. If Sakic can land a 27-28 year old with a clean injury history at that price, great. Pub talk with no name? I'm filing it next to every other trade rumour I've heard at the Ajax. 📊
Do the math before you argue.
TorontoLoyal's got a point tbh. The good ones always cost more than the rumour says 😅 but you just know Sakic's gonna find a way, he always does 🔥 our lot never make it easy though. Give MacK a wall on the left and we're scary 🙌💪
One love, one side ❤️
Funny how the cap number keeps growing every time this pub story gets retold, last week it was C$5-6M for a stay-at-home lefty, now Calgary's talking like the whole C$7M is earmarked for one guy. 📊
TorontoLoyal's sample-size argument holds up, mind you: shutdown lefties who actually eat penalty-kill minutes don't come cheap, and the rumour price is usually the agent's floor, not the closing number. But I'd pump the brakes one step earlier, until someone shows me the actual cap space figure from a real source, we're building a shopping list on a bartender's arithmetic. Remember how many "done deals" we've chased through this forum before? I'll believe the wall on MacKinnon's blind side when I see the name on a press release, not a napkin.
Context beats a bare stat.
RideOrDie the number isn't growing, people are just rounding up to what a real top-four guy actually costs 😤 and honestly who cares. Point is we need a wall back there. Remember when our D got walked in that playoff game and MacK had to backcheck himself into the ground? I was at the pub for that one, nearly put my fist through the screen 😱
Sakic pulled off magic before, he can do it with C$7M or whatever's actually under the cap. Gimme a name and I'll argue, till then I'm backing them all day 🔥💪
You don't abandon your own.
Put me on the roof in Kelowna all summer, heard this same rumour then too 🤡 and in reality nobody's named a name yet. Weird that eh? 😏
Any stat can be bent.
RideOrDie has a point, no name in a month of pub talk. I'll believe the C$7M story when a contract is signed, nothing less.
Where's the proof?
Don't laugh, guys, but weren't we in almost this exact spot last summer? Some C$6M defenceman everyone swore was basically done, and then nothing ever got signed and we all just quietly moved on 😅 Maybe this year it's real, maybe I'm wrong, but I've learned not to count on anything until the paperwork exists. Time will tell 🙏
Learn something new every day.
@ReginaLoyal nah don't apologise, you're dead right, we did this exact dance last summer with a C$6M guy everyone had basically skating with MacK already 😂 My buddy lost fifty bucks on that rumour being real, so at least someone profited. What odds you'd give this one actually gets signed? 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
RideOrDie has a point, no name in a month of pub talk. I'll believe the C$7M story when a contract is signed, nothing less.
@Harry_RinkRat1993 nah I'm with you tbh, pen on paper or it didn't happen 🤷♂️ month of pub talk and still no name? that's how these things always die
only thing that worries me is we actually NEED the shutdown guy this year more than last, so my heart's gonna believe every rumour even when my brain says chill 😅 story of being a fan eh
One love, one side ❤️