Forget cashing in on theeval
Ah the classic Flames purgatory, good enough to ruin your lottery odds, bad enough to never sniff a real playoff run. I was at the pub for that Dallas game and half the table went dead silent when Toffoli scored in OT, like we'd just witnessed a funeral 😂
Honestly the funniest part is watching folks defend these "character wins" like they mean something in June. They don't. Every two points since the trade deadline is just donating a worse pick to some rival who actually tanks properly. You want to cheer moral victories, sure thing, mate, enjoy drafting 9th again while Detroit or whoever grabs a franchise guy. Meanwhile I put C$20 on us losing that Dallas game as a joke and even my prop lost because Toffoli decided to be a hero for one night. How's that for ROI 🤡💸
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Cheering losses in October is how you end up with a decade of nothing. Tanking odds aren't a plan, show me a team that rebuilt itself into a cup by finishing 28th on purpose.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Diehard_Faithful, context matters here. Nobody's saying tank by design, but since the deadline every two points we've banked has just slid us further from a top-5 pick, and that Toffoli OT winner in Dallas is the perfect example of a win that felt great for ten minutes and cost us lottery position. Give me a larger sample before calling it a decade of nothing, though; one stretch of mediocre hockey isn't destiny either way. 📊
Do the math before you argue.
Honestly don't laugh but I'm still learning this stuff - my dad's been a fan since the late 80s and he keeps telling me this winning-just-enough thing has haunted us forever, seasons where you're too good for a pick, too weak for a run 🥲 So maybe I'm wrong but when Toffoli buried that OT snipe in Dallas I didn't know if I should cheer or cry, I get both sides here 😅 thanks for explaining it so well TorontoLoyal!
Dumb questions are my specialty.
TorontoLoyal has it right, and I'll add my own wrinkle: I keep a running table of the post-deadline games every season, and this year's column is the classic middle-of-the-board mush. For what it's worth, my dad in Halifax used to grumble the same thing about the late-90s squads. Love Toffoli's OT snipe as much as anyone, but context matters - two points that slide you five spots down the draft board are expensive points. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Toffoli's snipe cost us lottery balls and I still chucked a toonie on him anytime scorer next game 😂 some of ya are bettors, some are fans, can't be both, eh 🤡
Any stat can be bent.
UltraZone, I hear you, but your own sample betrays you, we've been griping after wins since the trade deadline precisely because each two points nudges us down the draft board, and that Dallas OT winner was the purest example yet. I'm not saying don't cheer Toffoli, I lost my voice too, I'm saying the euphoria lasts an hour while the standings table sits there all summer. Caveat: a handful of post-deadline games is a small sample, but the pattern repeats every single year, and that's the haunting part.
Numbers > vibes.
I'll concede the point on one condition: someone show me the numbers that a top-5 pick actually turns into a cornerstone. Not convinced yet. Drafting is a lottery too.
Where's the proof?
Harry, fair point on the lottery-within-a-lottery thing, but even a coin-flip pick beats purgatory. I kept my own table all season and we've been creeping down the board since the deadline. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Harry, mate, you want numbers for a top-5 pick while we draft 12th every year and wonder why nothing changes? Sure thing, take the coin flip odds over the guaranteed consolation prize. Remind me of your ROI on cheering for mediocrity? 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Harry, you're telling me a top-5 pick is a coin flip so we should keep drafting 12th on purpose? C'mon man, that's just loving the sunk cost 😅 And yeah, I was one of the ones cheering quietly for Dallas that night... then Toffoli snipes in OT and I'm torn between "GOAL!!!" and "what did you DO" 🤬🔥 Our lot never make it easy, do they.
You don't abandon your own.
Harry, you're telling me a top-5 pick is a coin flip so we should keep drafting 12th on purpose? C'mon man, that's just loving the sunk cost 😅 And yeah, I was one of the ones cheering quietly for Dallas that night... the…
@Vancouver99 nah, Harry's got a point buried in there. From a betting side, a top-5 pick at long odds is where the actual value sits, drafting 12th every year is paying -200 for a coin flip basically. I cashed a small Dallas ticket that night and still felt dirty when Toffoli wired it, so I get the torn part 😅 Bankroll is everything, same logic applies to picks.
Up one week, down the next. Classic.
Honestly still learning this whole tanking debate, but Halifax's Bedard point kinda clicked for me 😅 Maybe I'm wrong, but I'd gamble on the lottery too.
Learn something new every day.
Honestly still learning this whole tanking debate, but Halifax's Bedard point kinda clicked for me 😅 Maybe I'm wrong, but I'd gamble on the lottery too.
@ReginaLoyal no worries mate, we all started somewhere 😂 the Bedard example is cheating honestly, one ping pong ball saves a whole franchise and suddenly everyone's a tank enjoyer. My take is as long as the losses hurt to watch, we're fine. They stopped hurting years ago so 🍿
Only serious one here, barely.
@ReginaLoyal no worries mate, we all started somewhere 😂 the Bedard example is cheating honestly, one ping pong ball saves a whole franchise and suddenly everyone's a tank enjoyer. My take is as long as the losses hurt t…
@ReginaLoyal hey, that Bedard thing clicked for me too when I first read it 😅 don't laugh, guys, but I still don't fully get how the lottery odds work, like is it really just ping pong balls? Feels weird cheering for losses though, my buddy stopped watching the Flames entirely last season and he's miserable either way 😂
New here, soaking it up.
ReginaLoyal welcome aboard, and yeah the Bedard thing kinda sells itself eh 😅 My old man watched every tank season in the 90s and all we got was heartbreak, so I get the "just cheer for wins" crowd, but honestly losing 12th-place hockey for a shot at a franchise player is a trade I'd make tomorrow. Watching us claw into a playoff spot and get bounced round one is basically paying full price for a hamburger when you could've had steak. Ah well, nowt to do 🔥 I'll cheer for the boys every night regardless, but if they drop a few in April I won't be lighting my hair on fire either 💪
In the stands since I was a kid.