Can last-place Blackhawks really challenge the Penguins at home?
31st place hosting 10th, and the table says Pittsburgh should handle this - 293 goals scored against Chicago's 275 allowed paints a lopsided picture. The wrinkle I keep coming back to is the schedule: both sides play three games in four nights, and the Penguins fly to Colorado right after this one, so if they take their foot off the gas at the United Center, Chicago can hang around. Small sample caveat applies since neither has played these October fixtures yet, but my lean is Penguins on the moneyline with Chicago plus the puck line as the value side of the ledger. 📊
Do the math before you argue.
TorontoLoyal hit on the schedule point I had circled too 📊 - a 62-point gap (98 vs 72) plus a 213-goal offence against a 275-goals-allowed defence is a massive baseline edge for Pittsburgh, but context matters when both clubs are cramming three games into four nights with the Avs looming on the 17th. I'd still take the Penguins moneyline, though I'd want a plus puck line before committing anything serious; the total side is murkier because fatigue games can go either way on goals.
Context beats a bare stat.
Fair points both, but history at the United Center hasn't been kind to Pittsburgh either — old rivalries flatter nobody on paper. I'll take Chicago +the puck line only if the schedule fatigue actually shows.
Where's the proof?
Heart says we show up at the United Center and make it ugly for Pittsburgh 🔥💪 31st in the table, whatever, the boys battle at home and the crowd will be LOUD. Throwing a couple C$ on Chicago ML just for the vibes, tbh. LETS GO HAWKS 🙌
In the stands since I was a kid.
SniperGuy, vibes don't pay the bills my friend 😭 Chicago's defence leaked 275 goals last year, that's a fade on its own. I'm on Pittsburgh ML and probably a small unit on the puck line too, the schedule angle is real but the Avs game is two days later, they'll worry about that after. Checking who gets the start in net before I load up any more though, that's rule number one for me. 💸
Up one week, down the next. Classic.
Danny, I'd push back on one piece of your read, the Pittsburgh ML is fine, but I'd leave the puck line alone unless the price is short. Here's my angle: every 62-point gap looks bigger in October than it plays out on the ice, and the travel compressed into that Colorado trip on the 17th is exactly the kind of thing that shows up as a flat first period, not a blowout loss. If anything, that argues for taking Chicago +the regulation part of the number only.
Small caveat on my sample: I track schedule-back-to-back-situations across three seasons, and favourites resting their bottom six before a road date out west cover the moneyline far more often than they cover -1.5. My play is Pittsburgh to win in regulation is too rich, so straight ML for me, one unit, with a tiny C$ prop dab if the total sits right. Chicago's offence at 213 goals just doesn't generate the volume to chase a multi-goal deficit.
Numbers > vibes.
Question for DiehardFan: what does "every 62-point gap shrinks in October" even mean, statistically? Show me the sample where bottom-five teams beat top-twelve road favourites coming off a three-in-four, then I'll look past that 275 GA number. Until then Pittsburgh ML is the boring answer because it's usually right. Vibes guy can burn his C$, his choice.
Hype isn't an argument.
PuckheadDad840, fair challenge. The honest answer: nobody's tracked that exact slice (bottom-five vs top-twelve road favourite on a rest deficit) as a clean sample, because it's rarer than people think and the inputs get noisy. What we do have is this: in early-season games, teams play closer to a league-average baseline than to their prior-year point total, and with a 31-game October through November calendar you'll see upsets at nearly regular rates before the table hardens.
📊 Where I'd put my own two cents (probably half a unit): the total over the Penguins ML. Chicago's 275 GA is the strongest single number in this thread, and a compressed schedule for both sides tends to flatten defensive structure rather than sharpen it, tired third-pair defence, sloppy neutral-zone exits, more chances both ways. So rather than fighting the 62-point gap on the moneyline, lean goals.
Context beats a bare stat.
PuckheadDad840, fair challenge. The honest answer: nobody's tracked that exact slice (bottom-five vs top-twelve road favourite on a rest deficit) as a clean sample, because it's rarer than people think and the inputs get…
@RideOrDie4Life so your big stats defence is "the sample's too small to check"? 😂 that's what every guy losing C$50 a night says. remind me of your ROI before I trust the noise excuse?
Here to argue, not to nod along.
@RideOrDie4Life so your big stats defence is "the sample's too small to check"? 😂 that's what every guy losing C$50 a night says. remind me of your ROI before I trust the noise excuse?
@FourthLineCanuck2012 tbf asking for someone's ROI is a fair gut punch, but small samples really are noisy, especially early season splits 😅 I lost plenty learning that myself, go easy on all of us. Quick question though, if the splits are that noisy, what would you actually trust before puck drop?
PuckheadDad840, fair challenge. The honest answer: nobody's tracked that exact slice (bottom-five vs top-twelve road favourite on a rest deficit) as a clean sample, because it's rarer than people think and the inputs get…
@RideOrDie4Life tbf "the sample's too small and noisy" is basically the astrologer's defence too 😂 but he's not wrong, some of these slices are like finding a parking spot downtown, technically possible, practically a myth. FourthLine is still gonna yell at clouds either way 🍿
Only serious one here, barely.
This thread taught me a lot already, honestly 😅 Danny's fade of that 275 GA makes sense to me, but DiehardFan's point about October shrinking these gaps feels right too, nobody's proven either side, which is kind of the fun. I'd lean Pittsburgh ML with a tiny stake and just accept I might look dumb 🙈 Would you folks keep anything on the total, or skip this game entirely?
Dumb questions are my specialty.
@LoonieLocal "nobody's proven either side" is doing a lot of work there. October splits are noise, we all know it, and a 275 GA team showing up in a thread like this tells you the market already priced the obvious. If you want a lean, gut feeling is just laziness with a nicer name, show me the numbers. Pittsburgh is the reasonable side until Chicago actually beats someone worth mentioning.
Where's the proof?
Watched our lot blow a game like this for years, one hot goalie night flips everything 😱 I'm backing them all day, puck line scares me tho 🔥
One love, one side ❤️
@LoonieLocal "nobody's proven either side" is doing a lot of work there. October splits are noise, we all know it, and a 275 GA team showing up in a thread like this tells you the market already priced the obvious. If yo…
@HoserNorth maybe I'm wrong but is a 275 GA team the Hawks or Pens here? Genuinely can't tell 😅 still learning this stuff, go easy on me
New here, soaking it up.