Be honest, Blueshirts: this team goes nowhere until we admit the
Six minutes of five-on-three at the Garden and we scored off a skate. Say that out loud and tell me the powerplay works. The guy next to me at the pub nearly wore his pint over that one, and honestly who could blame him.
Here's my polarising take: this team goes nowhere until everyone admits the powerplay IS the system, not some side dish. Every five-on-four looks like a drill run by committee, cycle along the wall, one low-percentage look, reset. Meanwhile the PK teams just sit in the box laughing. If the even-strength attack had any teeth I'd shrug it off, but it doesn't, so the man-advantage has become the whole identity and a bad one at that. Remind me what we actually generated on that last homestand with the extra man? Crickets. Provocative enough for ya 😏🤡
Here to argue, not to nod along.
A deflected goal still counts as one on the scoresheet. Ugly powerplay goals count the same as pretty ones, and one bad five-on-three doesn't indict the whole scheme.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Diehard, I hear you on ugly goals counting, but one sample only tells you so much and six minutes of five-on-three is a big enough slice of it. Even with the man advantage twice over you generate one deflection off a skate, that tells me the entries and the setup aren't creating looks, the goal just happened. Context matters here, a working scheme buries that chance before anyone's pint is in danger 📊
Do the math before you argue.
Nah but the pub guy is all of us 😂 six minutes of 5-on-3 and we're thanking a skate, c'mon. LoonieEh kinda has a point tho, blast it and crash the net, what's the worst that happens 🤷 ah well, nowt to do but hope they fix the entries soon 🤬
In the stands since I was a kid.
Blasting one-timers got us nowhere either last spring. Show me an entry with speed and a shooting lane, then I'll believe the "crash and pray" crowd.
Hype isn't an argument.
PuckheadDad840 has it right, the crash-and-pray stuff gets you nothing either if the entry is dead. I sat behind the glass for that 5-on-3 and the first fifteen seconds were two cross-ice passes nobody shot. Show me speed through the neutral zone and an actual lane, then I'll believe any system works. Until then, sideways passes into shins.
Where's the proof?
Fifteen seconds of cross-ice with no shot, that matches what I charted from the couch that night, and I keep a running sheet every game. Harry's got it right, entry speed decides everything, though I'd add the box knows our umbrella by now so even a clean entry dies if we don't change the look. I watched the 1-3-1 teams punish us with that same setup all last spring.
Context beats a bare stat.
Sam's couch charting is more effort than the actual staff put in 😂 sixteen games of same umbrella, same dead entries, I'd bet a C$50 prop even Laviolette can see it from the bench.
Show me your ROI first 😏
Sam charting on the couch is funny but Laviolette's seen more hockey than all of us combined 😅 Umbrella's stale though, gotta admit that much 💪🔥
One love, one side ❤️
Sam's sheet and Harry's seat behind the glass agree more than anyone's admitting here, that's my whole read. Entry speed, one stale look, six minutes of five-on-three wasted. Whether the fix is Laviolette's or the personnel's, I still can't tell from my couch charting, so I'm keeping the argument open 📊
Numbers > vibes.