Are we really buying at the deadline after limping into the playoffs
Honestly 93 points out of 82 with a plus-13 goal diff at Rogers Place tells me the roster's got gaps nobody's patching with a rental. Word going round the dressing room isn't exactly cheery either 🤫
Mortgaging picks for another first-round bounce? Nah. Source says the front office is split on this one, and I believe it, they're careful types. Stand pat and see what October brings, Kings away on the 14th will tell us plenty before anyone spends a dime. You'll all find out soon enough 😏
Dangle, "word going round the dressing room" is doing a lot of work in that post. Show me the numbers behind that whisper, because 93 points and a plus-13 through 82 at Rogers Place reads like a mediocre team, sure, but a rental doesn't fix mediocrity either way.
Where I'd push back slightly: standing pat has its own cost. 41 wins with a goal diff of 282-269 means the games were tight, and tight games in April get weird. A second-pair defenceman might be worth more than a first-rounder that lands 25th anyway. My problem is with the panic version of buying, not buying itself. Pay retail for a splash? No. Pay fair price for an actual hole? Maybe. Define the hole first, then we can argue.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Diehard, even you gotta admit 41 wins and a goal diff of 282-269 ain't screaming cup run 😅 I watched half those home games this year and the holes are RIGHT there. Trade the picks? Get in... the sea. Stand pat, let the young guys grow, ah well, nowt to do but ride it out 💪
In the stands since I was a kid.
Puckhead, I'm with you on standing pat, though I'd push back slightly on "ride it out" as a plan. A 282-269 diff over 82 games is a team that wins a bunch of close ones and loses a bunch of close ones, which usually means the fix is internal, not a rental.
Here's the caveat though, small sample alert doesn't apply to the season but it does apply to deadline rentals in general. Look at the history, a mid-tier buyer renting a top-six winger for a first-round exit gives up the pick and gets nothing back. The internal path is uglier and slower, and half this forum won't have the patience for it, but mortgaging picks off a 14th-place roster is how you end up mediocre AND empty. I've sat through enough of those springs at Rogers Place to know which smell I prefer.
Numbers > vibes.
DiehardFan's got it right. A minus-level 282-269 diff with 41 wins says close games both ways, and no rental fixes that. Stand pat, I'll believe in the kids when I see it.
Where's the proof?
Harry_RinkRat1993, mostly agreed, one caveat though. Plus-13 over 82 games is a coin-flip profile, and coin-flip teams rarely get rescued by a rental. But "stand pat" shouldn't mean sitting on your hands entirely. If the right deal is there for a third-round pick and a B-prospect, you take it. The mistake would be firsts and your better kids for a two-month rental, which is what half this thread seems to be arguing for.
I keep my own table every year and this version of the Oilers tracked almost exactly to the standings: tight games, thin margin, 282-269 tells you the defensive side needs work that no single deadline player covers. Small sample caveat on my sheet, one season is one season, but the pattern repeats. Context matters here. Fix the gaps internally, spend the picks only where the price is silly.
Do the math before you argue.
TorontoLoyal's caveat is fair, but who decides what a "B-prospect" is? Every GM in the league calls their throw-ins a B-prospect. 14th place with 93 points says show me the numbers first.
Hype isn't an argument.
Word going round the front office isn't keen on burning a first anyway, take that how you will 🤫 41 wins, 93 points, coin-flip diff, that screams tinkering not mortgaging. PuckheadDad's right, everyone's throw-in is a "B-prospect" till it isn't. Details in the DMs if you're curious 😏
Third rounder and a B-prospect? Sure. First? Nah, no way 🤬 Plus-13 ain't buying you a Cup run tbh.
In the stands since I was a kid.
@Dave_Slapshot same read here. A first for a team hovering around a coin-flip record is throwing good money after bad, I've cashed enough tickets on dumb longshots to know what value looks like. Give me the third and a throw-in all day, keep the pick and live with the drought if it comes to that.
Go easy on me here but what actually makes a prospect a "B-prospect" anyway 😅 Maybe I'm wrong but I'd rather they tinker than burn a first. Still learning this deadline stuff.
New here, soaking it up.