Look, we all love the fireworks
Honestly I laugh every time someone calls our system a glorified McDavid showcase. You lot watched the same games I did? Because when the forwards push the puck up high we leak chances in neutral zone transition like a screen door, and that's got nothing to do with 97 doing magic at the blue line. He can't backcheck three zones at once.
Whole thread of you will still blame the D corps though 🤡 I've hit the under on this exact pattern more times than I can count, my ROI doesn't complain. Laughable really, some of you would blame the zamboni driver before you'd admit the forwards quit skating back. 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Screen door defence with forwards up high? Pull the actual transition stats against it before you crown that a system flaw. Not convinced by vibes.
Sample first, conclusions after.
When the forwards go high and we get burned nobody says a word about D-zone structure, always McDavid takes the blame 😤 Whole team leaks chances, ah well, nowt to do 🔥💪
In the stands since I was a kid.
OldSchool has a point worth digging into, but I'd pump the brakes on calling it a systemic flaw until we've got a bigger sample. Small stretches of games can make the neutral zone look like a revolving door when the forwards pinch high, and one bad road trip in California can skew everything. Context matters here, so I'd want to see how we defend that rush over 15-20 games before blaming the structure instead of the personnel on any given night. 📊
Do the math before you argue.
back in the day we just called that lazy backchecking, kids 😄 every team I've watched since the 80s leaked chances when the forwards pinched. system or not, somebody's gotta come back low.
Watch as long as I have and you'll get it.
Jack's got half a point there, but "somebody's gotta come back low" is doing a lot of work in that sentence. Who? If it's McDavid or Draisaitl, then yeah, you've basically built a system where your two best players spend the shift protecting the exits instead of creating at them. That's a coaching choice, and Knoblauch owns it either way.
I'll accept the small-sample argument TorontoLoyal made, on condition that someone actually shows me the split between games where the forwards sit high and games where they cycle low. Nobody in this thread has done it, everyone's arguing about whether the eye test counts. As an economist I'd put it this way: if pushing high gets you more chances for and also more against, that's a tradeoff, and it's fine. But if the against column only shows up when the push fails, that's a design problem, not vibes. Show me which one it is and I'll shut up about it.
Where's the proof?
Fair question Harry, and honestly nobody's answered it yet. Depends how you count it, but if the answer is McDavid backchecking every shift, that's a system problem. 📊
Numbers > vibes.