Honest take, family: this rebuild should have been faster
Couple seasons of "growing pains" and the kids are still teaching的成绩 the same third-period collapses, so what exactly are we developing here? I like Rich, genuinely, but love doesn't fix odd-man rushes. Bet the puck line against us late and you've printed money all year, tell me again how that's a rebuild going to plan? 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Third-period collapses are on a roster missing a real top-pair defenceman, Victoria. Bedard, Vlasic and Reichel improving every month, that's development. I could be wrong about Rich, but the youth movement says otherwise.
Where's the proof?
Harry called it tbh 🔥 Bedard and Vlasic are clealry trending up, you don't fire the guy mid-development... Victoria, the third period bleeding is a roster problem, elite clubs have a true #1 D, we don't yet. I watched every collapse this year and the kids kept skating til the buzzer. That's coaching. Backing Rich all day 💪
You don't abandon your own.
I've kept my own tables on the odd-man rushes against, and the caveat is small sample, but the third-period pattern repeats too often to call it noise. Vlasic and the kids look sharper shift to shift, sure, that's real development, yet the structure keeps handing away chances after the 40-minute mark. Harry's right that the roster lacks a true number one D, but a good development coach should be tightening those habits by now, and Richardson hasn't shown it. Depends how you count it, but I lean with Victoria on this one.
Numbers > vibes.
Remember when Quenneville rebuilt on the fly and we still ate third-period leads alive? Word going round the press box is the player-side patience runs thinner than the fan-side, and those who know, know 😏 Details in the DMs, but watch how the bench handles the last five minutes Saturday.
Diehard's tables track with what I've scribbled down myself across the season, and I'd only add the usual caveat: one year of data with a roster this young is a shaky foundation for firing anyone. Harry's right that the kids are trending up - Bedard's decision-making with the puck looks nothing like October. But here's my worry. Development shows up in how you close games, and closing games is coaching structure as much as talent. I sat in 316 for the collapse last month, and the same neutral-zone exit failure happened three separate shifts in a row with nobody behind the bench adjusting. That's on the staff, not the roster.
So count me half-agreeing with Victoria: keep the patience, sure, but Richardson is on a shorter leash than the chant at the UC suggests. Watch the last five minutes Saturday like Winnipeg says, if the bench keeps freezing, that's your answer. 📊
Do the math before you argue.
TorontoLoyal, one shaky year of data is also how we ended up watching three straight springs on the couch my friend 😂 If the kids are "trending up" like Vancouver99 says, why do the same odd-man rushes keep killing us every third period with the SAME six defencemen? Saturday's last five minutes will tell us more than Diehard's whole spreadsheet, and I've got a prop on us blowing a lead, that's how little faith I've got left 💸
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Nah FourthLine you're kinda making my point for me 😅 Same six D, same third-period panic, and nobody's moved the needle in a year-plus? That's coaching, sorry. I love Rich too, the room clearly loves him, but the kids keep learning the same lesson every game and it's costing us wins we could actually bank 🔥
And Winnipeg_True with the "watch Saturday" stuff. C'mon brother, either drop it or don't 😂 I'll be at the pub Saturday anyway, couple pints and probably yelling at the screen again like always 🤬🤬 our lot never make it easy, but at some point growing pains gotta turn into growth. We'll see what the last five minutes look like 🍿
One love, one side ❤️
Show me the numbers, FourthLine. Roster this young with one year of data and you're already blaming coaching? Development trends upward over years. Not convinced.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Fair point on the sample size, Diehard, I'll believe it when I see it. But here's my live observation: watch who's on the ice in the last five minutes when we're up one, same pairing, same pinch, same two-on-one the other way, game after game. Development means adjustments, and the third-period scheme hasn't budged. One season is thin data, sure, but the pattern repeating itself isn't a spreadsheet problem, eh?
Hype isn't an argument.
PuckheadDad, that's exactly what I've been tracking in my own game notes. Same pairing pinned deep in the last five minutes, same two-on-one against, week after week. Diehard's right that a year is thin ice for judging development, but teaching kids to defend a lead is Year One material. Richardson seems like a lovely man; lovely doesn't survive the third period.
Context beats a bare stat.
Funny how everyone's preaching patience from behind a screen while I'm dropping good money on this club getting outskated every third period 😅 Love Rich as a person, truly, but two-on-ones against with the kids on ice in the final minutes? That's a coaching habit, and habits that repeat that often get taught. Sam's right, defending a lead is day-one stuff, anything else is an excuse.
Any stat can be bent.
Watch a single third period from section 317 and the pattern jumps off the ice, the same kids, same pinch, same odd-man rush back the other way. I keep my own notes and the repetition is real, but a year of data on teenagers is thin, so I'd separate two questions: whether the development is on track, and whether Richardson's late-game deployment helps it. On the second one, honestly, it's not that simple yet, teaching a lead defence might just be the next lesson, not a failed one. 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Watch a single third period from section 317 and the pattern jumps off the ice, the same kids, same pinch, same odd-man rush back the other way. I keep my own notes and the repetition is real, but a year of data on teena…
@RideOrDie4Life I've only watched on TV but even I noticed the same late-game pattern 😅 honestly I keep hoping it's just kids learning. Is coaching or experience, in your notes?
Learning from the veterans, go easy 🙏
@RideOrDie4Life I've only watched on TV but even I noticed the same late-game pattern 😅 honestly I keep hoping it's just kids learning. Is coaching or experience, in your notes?
@RobbedAgain_Merchant I noticed it too just from the couch, so you're not alone 😅 My gut says coaching, kids can't be the ones fixing this. Any better answers in this thread?
Learn something new every day.