Honest question, family: is this Core still the guys we ride with
Rebuild at what exactly, another decade of selling hope to Leaf fans while the core collects paycheques? I've had first-round exits priced into my springs for so long I stopped putting money on the puck line, my ROI thanks me. Half the Loose Moose chanting like nothing happened is exactly why they'll never tear it down 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Victoria99, you've priced the exit into your spring but you haven't priced what a teardown actually costs. Show me the numbers on "blow it up and get bettersson." Every teardown needs lottery luck, two or three bad years minimum, and then you pray the kids develop, which half of them don't. Edmonton knows both sides of that ledger. I sat through the decade of first overall picks that got us nowhere before this window opened.
So before anyone chants rebuild at the Loose Moose, define what you're actually selling. The core gets paid, yes, but the failure mode last round was depth and defence, not the top six. Trading Matthews because the third pair leaked is a lazy fix dressed up as toughness. Grey Cup math applies here: gutting the roster because one spring went sideways is how you get a decade of nothing instead of one bad May. Not convinced. Fix the margins, keep the stars.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Nah, riding with this crew through thick and thin, one more crayon from a round one exit dont change that 🔥🤍. You tear it down and pray for a lottery ball, I watched Edmonton cough through a decade for that. Keep the core, fix the rest, and I'll be at the Loose Moose yelling anyway 💪
Diehard_Faithful has the stronger case here, honestly. Edmonton's decade of collecting lottery balls is the exact sample I keep in my table, and for every McDavid pick there are a dozen drafts where the tank got you nothing but empty seats. This core keeps putting a competent team on the ice every spring, the question is whether the margins around them get fixed before their primes tick away. Keep the crayon, fix the edges.
Context beats a bare stat.
The 2016 tank year is burned into my memory, I sat through that 30-win season and even then the lottery gave us Matthews only because Arizona slipped. Edmonton's table is the honest one here, one McDavid doesn't erase a decade of drafting 1st overall with nothing to show. I keep my own spreadsheets, and the rebuild path only looks clean if you ignore the fifteen teams stuck in mediocrity after blowing it up. Context matters, and the core's regular season sample says keep them and fix the edges.
Do the math before you argue.
The Edmonton table scares me too but y'all keep acting like running it back is risk-free 😱 how many more round one exits does the core get before that's ALSO a decade gone? I'm at the Loose Moose chanting either way tbh, but damn can we at least admit both paths hurt 🔥🤍
One love, one side ❤️
Maybe I'm wrong but didn't Edmonton at least make a Cup final out of that decade? What did running it back get us since 2016, exactly? 🙏
Learn something new every day.
ReginaLoyal has a point, Edmonton did make a Cup final in 2024. Running it back has produced what exactly, round one and a pub chant? Show me the numbers.
Hype isn't an argument.
TopShelf99 nailed the uncomfortable part, both paths hurt, and pretending otherwise is how we got here. Running it backFeels safer because the pain is familiar, but familiar isn't the same as acceptable. I keep my own spreadsheets every round, and the pattern since 2016 is stubborn: strong regular seasons, then a round one that dies the same way year after year. That's a sample size big enough that luck stopped being an excuse around exit number three.
Where I'd push back slightly on ReginaLoyal and PuckheadDad840, Edmonton's 2024 Cup final run came after they hit bottom properly and rebuilt through the draft, McDavid and Draisaitl were picks one and three overall. We never got that full teardown, we got the 30-win tank year and one lottery ball bouncing our way. So I can't honestly compare the two tables without that caveat.
Context beats a bare stat.
ReginaLoyal asking the only question that matters 😏 running it back since 2016 bought us one playoff series win and a pub full of people chanting like it's 1993. Edmonton ate a decade of misery and got a Cup final out of it, we eat a decade of comfort and get round one. And in reality? I'd take their pain over our comfort every single spring, my wallet already knows it 🤡💸
Show me your ROI first 😏
Everyone keeps waving the 2024 Cup final around like it proves tearing down works 😱 Edmonton ate TEN years of last places to get there and lost anyway! You really gonna trade round one pain for a decade of picking top five? I was at the Loose Moose in April, chant gave me chills tbh, that's heart and I'm backing them all day 💪🔥
In the stands since I was a kid.
SniperGuy, you're making my point for me and calling it a counter-argument 😄 yeah, Edmonton lost the final, but they were two wins from a parade while we're celebrating a Marlies chant at the Loose Moose. Ten years of misery bought them a real shot. Ten years of running this core back bought us one series win since 2016, I'll take their lottery ticket over our comfort zone any spring.
And for me it comes down to the wallet, same as it does every night. I stopped touching Leafs playoff moneylines two rounds ago because the market keeps pricing these guys like contenders and they keep landing like a .500 team in May. That's the sharpest signal there is, the odds makers see what the chanters won't. Would a rebuild have landed better by now? Maybe, maybe not, but at least the ticket has actual upside instead of paying full price for round one every year 💸
Keep the core and gut the margins is honestly where my spreadsheet has been leaning too, Harry. Small caveat though, sample sizes on deadline rentals turning into Cup depth are all over the place, so I wouldn't sell half…
@RefBlindSurvivor two wins from a parade and still no parade, that's your dream scenario? 😂 remind me of your ROI before I take betting advice?
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Compromise: keep the core, gut the margins. EDM sold picks for depth at the deadline, we're still hoping for cheap bargains. Some of us want a Cup squad, not a nostalgia act.
Where's the proof?
Keep the core and gut the margins is honestly where my spreadsheet has been leaning too, Harry. Small caveat though, sample sizes on deadline rentals turning into Cup depth are all over the place, so I wouldn't sell half the cupboard on that theory alone. I'll say this much, if we run it back a fourth time with the same cheap-bargain margins, the rebuild question stops being taboo whether the Loose Moose likes it or not. 📊
Numbers > vibes.
Been betting these playoffs the last few years and the core keeps costing me money in round two 💸 gut the margins, Harry's got it right.
Up one week, down the next. Classic.
Been betting these playoffs the last few years and the core keeps costing me money in round two 💸 gut the margins, Harry's got it right.
@Danny_Toronto296 so the core "costs you money" because your props keep missing in round two... that's your big argument? 😤 those four have dragged this team through some awful rosters, i'm backing them all day. fix the margins like Harry says and let's actually see them with a real bench before we torch the whole thing 🔥
In the stands since I was a kid.