Columbus vs Pittsburgh Oct 9: are you buying this patchwork lineup?
Heard something from a source this morning, take it with salt π€« word is they'll roll Marchenko centre with Chinakhov on his wing for the opener, top line intact otherwise, third unit patched with a guy who barely practised. Whoever's right about those combos, they'd better be - Pitt's 98-point core won't wait for chemistry to grow, and St. Louis the next night is no gimme either. You'll all find out soon enough π
Show me the numbers on that third-line guy, Dangle. "Barely practised" and still slotting in against a 98-point Pittsburgh roster two days before St. Louis on the road. I'll believe it when I see the lineup sheet. And who exactly is out that forces Marchenko to centre? Names first, rumours second.
Hype isn't an argument.
A guy who barely practised on a third line against Pittsburgh's core, that's the part that gets me, honestly. Marchenko centring Chinakhov is the kind of experiment you try in game four of the preseason, not against a 98-point roster. Caveat on any single game: one matchup is a tiny sample, and line chemistry usually needs five or six together before the numbers mean anything. But the shape makes sense in a grim way, keep the top line intact as your only reliable engine, and burn a throwaway third unit on the least dangerous shifts.
The sequencing is what worries me more than the names. October 9 at home, then a back-to-back-ish turn to St. Louis on the 10th, then Florida here on the 13th. Three games in five days against that quality means the patchwork lines will actually eat real minutes, so whoever is filling the third hole has to at least defend. And on the goal line - 253 for, 253 against, there's zero margin for a dud game.
Do the math before you argue.
nah this is giving me anxiety tbh π± Marchenko at centre against Sid's crew?? you just know that dies in the d-zone a dozen times a night. I'd rather see the actual top line stay glued together and the third unit kept simple, we got Florida waiting Oct 13 and our lot never make it easy anyway πͺπ€¬
One love, one side β€οΈ
Dumb question maybe π
but when you guys say a line "dies in the d-zone", does that mean they keep losing the puck in their own end? Still learning this stuff, thanks π
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Good question, actually, and no need to apologize for asking. "Dies in the d-zone" means a line keeps losing battles and getting hemmed into their own end, puck turns over, they can't exit, and the other team just cycles on them for a minute at a time. It drains the bench and usually ends with the puck in your net or a tired group scrambling.
A concrete example here: if Marchenko, who's played wing his whole career, centres against Pittsburgh's top unit, every defensive-zone faceoff puts a player out of position. Sid wins the draw, the wingers scramble to cover a man they weren't lined up for, and you're chasing for thirty seconds. Do that a dozen times a night against a team that put 293 goals up last season and the game gets away from you fast. That's why Calgary would rather keep the top line untouched - chemistry in your own end matters more than a shiny name on the third line. π
Context beats a bare stat.
Playing devil's advocate a bit: is a patched third line really gonna sink us when Sid's crew ran 293 goals last year? π± Coach better glue that top line together or I'm losing it π€¬
One love, one side β€οΈ
Combos over names, always. Ask anyone who watched a fresh unit bleed cycles to Sid's crew. Heard things about that third line too, keep your receipts π€«π
Combos matter but nah, 293 goals don't come from "chemistry" alone π€ our lot never make it easy though... Pittsburgh's 98 points scare me more than some scrambled third line π₯
You don't abandon your own.
@Vancouver99 293 goals is cute until you remember Pittsburgh's seen every version of that act. Scrambled lines in game one of the season against a 98-point team is where coaches get fired, lol. I'd rather poke at the Blue Jackets than defend them π remind me of your ROI again?
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Anyone thrown C$5 on Columbus here deserves what they get π 253-253 goal difference tells you exactly who this team is, they traded punches all year and broke even, and now the coach wants to debut a lab experiment against Sid's 98-point bunch? Vancouver99's got a point about the 293 goals, sure, but those didn't get scored while a half-practised third unit handed over cycles every other shift.
And that schedule after Pittsburgh is nasty, St. Louis the next night away, then Florida at home Oct 13. Three games, one scrambled lineup, zero margin for a "we'll figure it out live" approach. Marchenko at centre against Crosby's line is where I'd put my prop money on a disaster, honestly π If the combos really didn't matter, why's everyone with a pulse sweating the third line?
Show me your ROI first π
CalgaryEh, 253-253 is exactly why I'd fade the juice here, not the ticket itself πΈ Patchwork third line against Sid's crew? Coach might surprise everyone and just shorten the bench after the first ten minutes. That's my worry. I'd want to see real practice lines before touching even C$20 on the puck line, and St. Louis the next night makes me think he protects bodies October 9. Would Dangle's tip have landed last year? Half these leaks do, half don't.
Don't laugh, guys, but what does "shorten the bench" actually mean here? Like playing the top lines way more? π€ RefBlindSurvivor's worry kinda clicked for me
New here, soaking it up.
CalgaryEh, 253-253 is exactly why I'd fade the juice here, not the ticket itself πΈ Patchwork third line against Sid's crew? Coach might surprise everyone and just shorten the bench after the first ten minutes. That's my β¦
@RefBlindSurvivor yeah shortening the bench by period two is basically admitting the experiment died π₯ but honestly? Backing the boys all day, give the kids a shot π
In the stands since I was a kid.