Be honest, Leafs Nation: would you actually trade William Nylander
Seriously, are we still debating if we should kill our best scorer just because the blue line had a bad year? π The whole defensive panic thing reminds me of trying to calculate your ROI after a bad Saturday night bet, pure emotion. Keep flapping about trades; I'll just wait for the fanboys to pile in and explain why a defenceman is magically worth $10 million in points. π
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Emotion? I watched the same collapses you did, they're not a mood, they're on tape every April. Willy's point-per-game pace is lovely in February when nothing's on the line. Ask what it produced in the series where we needed a stop and got a rimmed-around puck instead. The guy at the pub was half wrong and half right, which is more than most of us manage.
Nobody's saying trade him for a bag of pucks. A legitimate top-pair defenceman fixes the actual recurring failure. I'll believe Willie as a playoff driver when I see it, and I've got several springs of receipts saying otherwise. Show me a deal that returns a real one and I'll listen.
Hype isn't an argument.
Nah, PuckheadDad, you don't trade a guy who puts up a point a game because April went sideways π€π₯ Everybody in that collapse share the blame, it's never one guy on tape. Watch Willy fly with the puck out of our own end and tell me we find THAT for a blue liner return π backing him all day, he's been loyal to us when half this city wanted him gone πͺ
One love, one side β€οΈ
I keep my little spreadsheet on this stuff and even I'll admit the point-per-game thing gets overrated in these debates. A point a game from a winger is real value, but the same stat in February and the same stat in a series where we needed one stop are two different animals. TopShelf is right that April was a group project, no arguing that. Yet Willie's the piece with the highest trade value on the roster outside the core forwards everyone protects, and a legit top-pair D fixes the exact hole that shows up on tape every spring.
So my honest answer? If the return is a true top-pair guy, I listen. If it's some "top-four with upside" package, hang up the phone. That's where the pub guy lost me, honestly, because driving Willie to the airport for a mid defenceman is just losing the trade on paper. π
Context beats a bare stat.
Back in the day we shipped too many good forwards away chasing defence and got burned every time π₯ backing Willy all day tbh
RefBlind, which good forward did we ship out chasing D that bit us? Because I remember Kessel winning a Cup in Pittsburgh after we panicked π nah, I drive Willie myself if it lands us a real top-pair guy who plays 25 hard minutes in April πͺ through thick and thin with the crest, ah well, nowt to do
In the stands since I was a kid.
Puckhead, you'd trade a 40-goal winger on a maybe defenceman? Show me the numbers on the return first. I'll believe it when I see it.
Where's the proof?
Harry asks for numbers on the return, and honestly that's where I land too. Willy's point-per-game pace is real value, no argument from me, but RideOrDie nailed it when he said February production and a series where you need one stop are different animals. I keep my own tables every round and even I can't pretend a 40-goal winger fixes a blue line that folds every spring. My caveat though: the return has to be an actual established top-pair defenceman playing big minutes, some "retooling" prospect package doesn't move the needle.
Funny thing, I argued this exact debate at the pub before a game at Scotiabank two seasons back and swore I'd never trade him, and I watched that series from the same seat and changed my mind by game six. So the guy driving him to the airport? Half wrong. The half of me that still remembers how thin the D depth gets in April wants proof the return plays 25 hard playoff minutes first. π
Context beats a bare stat.
I took Willy's side at the pub and I'll take it here too, that guy by the door was a plug π Point-per-game wingers who actually show up in November don't grow on trees, and every "top-pair defenceman" on the market comes with a busted contract or a 32-year-old body. The blue line collapsing every spring? That's on the whole group, not one guy's trade value. Remind me of your ROI, Harry, before you're shopping 40 goals for magic beans π€‘
Show me your ROI first π
Was at that exact pub table last Saturday before the Sens game and honest to god half those guys yelling "trade Willy" were wearing Nylander jerseys π you just know the panic dies the second he pots two in October.
Puckhead, 25 hard minutes in April from WHO exactly? Name me the guy coming back who does that AND doesn't cost us a first plus Knies' slot money. Harry's right, show me the return before I hand over a guy who drags this offence every single week. We collapsed in spring because we couldn't get a save and couldn't win a faceoff, not because Willie was eating too many points π€¬ Keep him, fix the blue line the boring way.
In the stands since I was a kid.
Josh, the pub plug had a point and you know it. Willy's pace is real, I keep a spreadsheet on the guy, but I've watched enough April hockey at Scotiabank to know 25 hard defensive minutes from a real top-pair guy changes a series in a way another 80-point October doesn't. Caveat though, sample of returns is tiny, so I'm not driving him to the airport either. Who exactly would you take back? π
Do the math before you argue.
TorontoLoyal, you keep a spreadsheet and still won't show us the April splits? That's the part that gets me every year. Everyone quotes the regular season pace like it carries over, and then May shows up and the conversation goes quiet.
Define "legit top-pair defenceman" before anyone answers the poll, because half this thread means a 34-year-old on expiring money and the other half means a 25-year-old nobody is trading anyway. Josh said every available one comes with a busted contract or a bad body, and he's basically right. Until someone names an actual target and what he'd cost, trading Willy is just panic with extra steps. Not convinced.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Diehard_Faithful, you're hitting the exact sore spot. I also keep my own table on Willy, and the regular season column is gorgeous, no argument there. But I pull the playoff rows separately every spring and they've never matched the pace, so anyone quoting the season-long number at me in April is selling something. Caveat though, and I say this every time the topic comes up: the sample is small and skewed by whoever we drew that year, so I don't treat it as gospel either. My personal detail is that my dad, who's had sens tickets since the Corel Centre days and hates this team with his whole soul, told me flat out last spring that he fears Nylander in a series more than anyone else in blue and white. Coming from him, that counted for more than any split I've run. So I'd keep Willy and hunt for a top-pair guy without moving him, unless the return is genuinely stupid good. π
Numbers > vibes.
Put Willy on the trade block and watch TorontoLoyal's spreadsheet cry π who exactly is giving us a top-pair D for him, the ghost of Doug Weight? π€‘
Any stat can be bent.
SteveFaceoff basically won the thread π who's paying a legit top-pair D for Willy? Nobody. So the pub plug can keep driving to the airport, alone π€‘π
Here to argue, not to nod along.
SteveFaceoff basically won the thread π who's paying a legit top-pair D for Willy? Nobody. So the pub plug can keep driving to the airport, alone π€‘π
Seriously @FourthLineCanuck2012?? You reckon weβre just gonna throw away a guy who brings top-six scoring for peanuts because the market is βtoughβ? π€·ββοΈ
Look, yeah, finding a D for a guy like Willy is tough, but thats not the point. The point is we HAVE a top guy at wing and you are out here trying to sell our roster to Twitter trolls. My heart says he belongs right here, full stops. We bleed for this team and through thick and thin we have to support the core guys. Stop being so toxic and let the Leafs play their game!! πͺπ₯
@DaveUltra agree bro, Willy at top-six scoring for peanuts? you just know some GM panics in June πͺ keep him, who else kills teams on the rush like that π€π₯
In the stands since I was a kid.
@FourthLineCanuck2012 you're celebrating way too early lol, Dave's got a point that nobody's pricing Willy fair until some GM gets desperate in June π€£ also side note but if we're trading him for a "top-pair D" who takes the pass on that pp1 unit, you? me holding my pint at the pub watching our powerplay die? thought so π
Came to laugh, stayed for life πΏ
SteveFaceoff basically won the thread π who's paying a legit top-pair D for Willy? Nobody. So the pub plug can keep driving to the airport, alone π€‘π
@FourthLineCanuck2012 nah man, market being quiet now means nothing... GMs get desperate in June and that's when the real offers show up π€¬ who said anything about a top-pair D anyway, flip Willy for picks plus a young D and go from there. You and Steve just wanna dunk on us for likes lol
In the stands since I was a kid.