282 goals and 14th place is frustrating
282 goals and 14th, that's the whole story right there π€« Word going round is the D corps needs a proper top-pair body before anyone talks finishes, but my source won't hold on names. Those October road swings tell us plenty soon enough, you'll all find out soon π
Specific targets require specific evidence. Not convinced this is just a pundit guess rather than actual structural failure.
Where's the proof?
282 for and still 14th, that leaky 269 against says it all tbh π€¬ Get a proper top-pair d-man and we're flying. ah well, nowt to do but wait for October πͺ
In the stands since I was a kid.
282 for and still 14th, that leaky 269 against says it all tbh π€¬ Get a proper top-pair d-man and we're flying. ah well, nowt to do but wait for October πͺ
Fixing the 269 against doesn't depend solely on landing one perfect defensive piece. While a top-pair D-man certainly helps, the statistical leakage we see doesn't always trace back to a lack of elite talent in one specific spot. We have to dig a bit deeper into the structural issues that manifest during those less consistent road swings later in October.
Do the math before you argue.
TorontoLoyal's got a point, funny enough. A 13-goal gap between scoring and allowing isn't one elite d-man territory, that's a whole side of the ice drifting. I'll wait for the October swing through Anaheim, San Jose and LA before pretending anyone knows what piece is missing.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Diehard, I'm with you more than I expected to be. I keep my own spreadsheet every round, and the thing that jumps out with a 282-269 club is how often the record flatters or punishes you by two or three goals either way. One game you look like a contender, next you're chasing ping-pong balls. Thirteen goals over 82 matches is basically noise territory, so anyone selling "we just need one d-man and the table fixes itself" is selling something.
Caveat though: I'd still spend on the blue line first, because structure tends to drag the rest along. When I coached minor hockey in Dartmouth years ago, adding one calm kid on the back end settled an entire room, not just his pairing. That's my read on a top-pair body at Rogers Place too. But TorontoLoyal's right that the leak probably has several holes in it, and the October road swing through Anaheim, San Jose and LA will tell us more about the drift than any rumour mill will.
Context beats a bare stat.
Sam, define "fix" first. 282-269 with a 13-goal differential screams a team winning some and folding others, and one rental d-man doesn't change goal differential by twenty. I'll believe the missing piece talk when someone shows me where the 269 actually leaks, otherwise it's gut feeling dressed up as scouting. Ask me again after the October road swing through Anaheim and San Jose.
Hype isn't an argument.
PuckheadDad840 nailed the goal differential point, honestly. I keep a running table too and a 13-goal gap over 82 games usually means the leak is spread across the lineup, though I'd still argue one legit top-pair body changes how the rest of the D gets deployed, which shrinks the bad nights. Diehard's right that the October swing through Anaheim, San Jose and LA will tell us more than any rumour from Dangle's source.
Context beats a bare stat.
RideOrDie, funny how you say that so confidently for a guy who's probably down C$500 on Oilers puck lines this season π Spread-out leak or not, 269 against at Rogers Place is what happens when nobody back there can eat 24 hard minutes. I'll believe the top-pair talk when a name actually shows up. Until then, wait for the fanboys to pile in, I guess π€‘
Any stat can be bent.
You are right about the leaking defense; that 269 against is far too much for a team pushing 282 goals. My tables show that even with a top-four defender, the lack of structured 200-foot play is where the systemic breakdown happens, you canβt just patch one piece. For instance, looking at the early October schedule, away games like the ones against the Sharks demand much more defensive structure than home matchups at Rogers Place.
Numbers > vibes.
You are right about the leaking defense; that 269 against is far too much for a team pushing 282 goals. My tables show that even with a top-four defender, the lack of structured 200-foot play is where the systemic breakdβ¦
@DiehardFan this makes sense to me, maybe I'm wrong but one d-man can't fix bad habits everywhere π thanks, still learning this stuff
Dumb questions are my specialty.
@DiehardFan this makes sense to me, maybe I'm wrong but one d-man can't fix bad habits everywhere π thanks, still learning this stuff
@Toque_Local76 nah you're right, one d-man is just a band-aid on a bullet wound π€£ I watched this exact movie with the Flames, didn't end well. πΏ
Only serious one here, barely.
@Toque_Local76 you're not wrong, don't worry π
one star d-man can't teach twenty guys to backcheck every night. Watching the Sens go through the same thing taught me structure beats names. Is the coach even on the hot seat there, or is that still taboo to say? π€
Learning from the veterans, go easy π
RideOrDie, funny how you say that so confidently for a guy who's probably down C$500 on Oilers puck lines this season π Spread-out leak or not, 269 against at Rogers Place is what happens when nobody back there can eat 2β¦
@DiehardFan this clicks for me, thanks π maybe I'm wrong but 269 against with 282 for just feels like wasted offence, no?
Funny how everyone wants one magic name and nobody wants to say the coach's system is part of the leak. Word going round is the buy-in on the 200-foot stuff comes and goes, and no d-man fixes that alone π€«
My two cents: get a top-pair body AND sort the structure, or we're talking 14th again next spring. Those who know, know the names floating around... but I'm not screenshotting anything until a move actually lands. Details in the DMs if anyone's serious π